Opinion: Kim Reynolds accused of racism, but her ad has no hint of racism
- Oops!Something went wrong.Please try again later.
Iowa Republican Gov. Kim Reynolds, a white female who is running for re-election against a Black female opponent, stands accused of … racism. The Iowa Democratic Party chairman, a Black man, leveled the charge against her. Reynolds' sin? She put out a political ad a few weeks ago attacking her opponent for what Reynolds considers bad Democratic policies. In response, Iowa Democratic Party chair Ross Wilburn tweeted: “We need to call this what it is: a cheap, racist and dangerous stunt using harmful stereotypes to score political points.”
Did Reynolds’ ad denounce her opponent as “a low-IQ individual,” as Donald Trump called Black Rep. Maxine Waters, a California Democrat, a put-down that CNN legal analyst Jeffrey Tobin described as “racist”? Of course it was not “racist” when Waters, a Cal State sociology major, questioned the intelligence Dr. Ben Carson, the Yale and University of Michigan Medical School grad and the black former head of pediatric neurosurgery at Johns Hopkins and Trump’s choice for housing secretary. About Carson, Waters said, “This guy just doesn't have the background, the capability, the intelligence to do the job. He doesn't know what he's doing." No, Reynolds did not do that.
Did Reynolds, like Hillary Clinton, characterize “half” of the supporters of her opponent as “irredeemable” and consigned to a “basket of deplorables"? No, Reynolds said nothing of the sort.
More:Letters: Kim Reynolds commercial is accurate, fair and compelling
More:Editorial: Indefensible ads like Kim Reynolds' can never make Iowa a better place
Did Reynolds, as did President Joe Biden, denounce her opponent’s supporters as “extreme” adherents of “semi-fascism”? Biden, days later, added: “MAGA Republicans do not respect the Constitution. They do not believe in the rule of law. They do not recognize the will of the people. … They promote authoritarian leaders, and they fan the flames of political violence that are a threat to our personal rights.” Never mind the long list of Democratic “election deniers” and “extreme” adherents of “semi-fascism” including Al Gore, Hillary Clinton, Barbara Boxer, Jimmy Carter, Stacey Abrams and Rep. Bennie Thompson, the chairman of the Jan. 6 committee. No, Reynolds’ ad did nothing of the sort.
Oh, by the way, how is Reynolds doing as a governor? In a July 2022 Des Moines Register/Mediacom Iowa Poll, Reynolds held a 17-point lead over her opponent. The libertarian Cato Institute grades governors, A through F, based on their tax and spending record. In 2020 — the last Cato report card — Reynolds received a A, one of only four governors to score that high.
So what in the name of the Adolf Hitler/fascism/KKK did the “racist” 30-second ad actually say and depict? Well, it starts out with Rep. Cori Bush, a Missouri Democrat, who is Black, saying, “Defunding the police has to happen.” Then it cuts to Reynolds, sitting at a table, who says: “Watching the news, you wonder. Has the rest of the country lost its mind?” Reynolds then says: “Attacks on the police. Open borders. Paying people not to work. Aren’t you glad you live in Iowa?” This was accompanied with three quick visuals: a violent street protest; a video of the southern border being overrun; and a sign that reads “From Work To Welfare.” The last 10 seconds shows Reynolds walking down a Main Street-like sidewalk and passing storefronts. She says: “Here we still have common sense. We kept businesses open and kids in school. We cut taxes, support our police. Because in Iowa, America still works.”
That’s it.
No pickup truck dragging a Black man chained to the bumper? No cross burning on the lawn of a Black Des Moines family? No fist-shaking mob of Aryan brothers waving the Confederate battlefield flag while marching in the middle of the street in a Black neighborhood? C’mon, Governor, raise your game!
I promptly challenged Mr. Wilburn, via Twitter, to a debate at a time and place of his choosing. I want him to enlighten me on exactly how and why a normal, sentient human being could deem this standard political ad “racist.” So far, no response from the chairman.
Larry Elder is host of "The Larry Elder Show."
This article originally appeared on Des Moines Register: Opinion: Kim Reynolds accused of racism, but her ad is not racist
