NYC officials announce hate crime charge in stabbing death of gay dancer O'Shae Sibley

Jeanine Santucci, USA TODAY
Updated ·2 min read
185

A teenager was arrested and charged with murder as a hate crime in the stabbing death of O'Shae Sibley, a gay man who was fatally stabbed in a confrontation at a Brooklyn gas station, authorities said Saturday.

Police said Sibley, a 28-year-old professional choreographer, was stabbed to death July 29 after the confrontation between a group of friends dancing to a Beyoncé song and another group of young men who taunted them with derogatory slurs.

A 17-year-old suspect, who wasn't named, was in custody and was facing a charge of murder in the second degree, charged as a hate crime, and criminal possession of a weapon, the New York Police Department announced at a news conference Saturday.

Sibley's death has drawn national attention and outrage among New York City's LGBTQ community after authorities said they were investigating the case as a possible hate crime. Beyoncé and filmmaker Spike Lee both paid tribute to Sibley online.

Sibley and a group of friends were at a Brooklyn gas station and dancing to music playing from a car when they were approached by another group of young men who told them to stop dancing and "harassed" them, according to Joseph Kenny, assistant chief of the Detective Bureau.

Kenny said investigators interviewed witnesses and looked at video footage to determine that the group, including the suspect, used "derogatory" language, including homophobic and anti-Black slurs against Sibley and his friends.

O'Shae Sibley, who was fatally stabbed at a Brooklyn gas station on July 29, 2023, was a 28-year-old professional dancer and choreographer.
O'Shae Sibley, who was fatally stabbed at a Brooklyn gas station on July 29, 2023, was a 28-year-old professional dancer and choreographer.

Kenny said the groups had a verbal confrontation that turned physical and lasted for about four minutes. The suspect and Sibley "come together" in conflict before the suspect retreated while "striking" Sibley once in the chest, Kenny said. The suspect then fled.

Mayor Eric Adams said Sibley's life was lost to something "clearly that was a hate crime."

'REST IN POWER': Beyoncé, Spike Lee pay tribute to O'Shae Sibley, stabbed while dancing

Sibley, from Philadelphia, performed with the dance company Philadanco. He was also part of the New York City house and ballroom LGBTQ culture, according to Lee Soulja Simmons, executive director of the New York City Center for Black Pride.

"We wrestle with this death. We wrestle with hate crimes. We wrestle with people in our community constantly facing discrimination not just because you're Black but because you represent LGBT," Simmons said Saturday. "He did not deserve to die in that way."

One witness of the confrontation, Summy Ullah, said in interviews that the people in conflict with Sibley's group complained that Sibley and his friends' behavior offended them as Muslims. Some leaders of the area's Muslim community condemned the slaying.

“The weight of this loss is felt deeply, not just by the family and friends of O’Shae, but by all of us who value life, peace and justice," Soniya Ali, the executive director of the Muslim Community Center, said Saturday.

Contributing: The Associated Press

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: O'Shae Sibley death: Teen arrested, charged in stabbing