Retaining third-graders will create more trauma for students | Opinion
Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) are traumatic experiences that occur during childhood, such as abuse, neglect, household dysfunction, and exposure to violence. In response to the growing body of research linking these experiences to a range of negative health, social, and educational outcomes in adulthood, policymakers have become increasingly focused on children’s trauma.
Two years ago Tennessee lawmakers may have unwittingly embedded an adverse childhood experience into Tennessee code: mandatory third grade retention. This law goes into effect this year and requires students not testing at “met expectations” or “exceeded expectations” – according to Tennessee Comprehensive Assessment Program (TCAP) English Language Arts (ELA) results, to be retained or complete a summer remediation program. Even children who meet these requirements may be held back after fourth grade if they do not demonstrate “adequate growth.”
While the intent of the law is to promote reading in the early grades as a way to set students up for success in future learning, it seems likely to have significant unintended negative consequences.
Retention in third grade is a controversial policy that involves holding back students who fail to meet minimum ELA proficiency standards.
Counterpoint:Tennessee should stay the course until every student can read on grade level | Opinion
Four arguments against third-grade retention
While the intention behind this policy is to improve student achievement and ensure they are adequately prepared for later grades, there is evidence to suggest that retaining students in third grade may have negative impacts that outweigh any potential benefits. Here are several arguments against third grade retention for poor ELA test scores:
Lack of evidence for effectiveness: Research has shown that retention in early grades is not an effective solution for improving student achievement in the long-term. In many cases, students who are held back in early grades end up performing worse than their peers in later grades.
Damages student confidence: Retention can lead to feelings of shame and frustration. When students are held back in early grades, they may feel as though they have failed and are not smart enough, damaging their motivation to learn and their future academic success.
Widens achievement gaps: Retention can contribute to the widening of achievement gaps between students from different socioeconomic backgrounds. Children from low-income families are more likely to be retained in early grades due to limited access to high-quality early childhood education and support at home. This reinforces a cycle of poverty and underachievement.
Increased risk of dropping out: Research has shown that students who are retained are more likely to drop out, with serious implications for their future academic and career prospects.
Hear more Tennessee Voices: Get the weekly opinion newsletter for insightful and thought provoking columns.
High quality tutoring and summer learning opportunities can be beneficial, but there is little to no evidence that either Tennessee’s summer school program (Learning Loss Bridge Camps) or the tutoring program (Tennessee Accelerating Literacy and Learning Corps) established by the law are effective at improving student achievement. Both programs were thrown together quickly after the passage of the law. There have been no independent evaluations of how effective these programs actually are.
A better approach would focus on very early evaluation for struggling readers, and a robust program of academic supports and interventions beginning in kindergarten and continuing as long as needed. Retention should be limited to Pre-K, kindergarten or possibly first graders; third grade is too late.
While the intention behind retention is to improve student achievement, third and fourth grade retention is likely to add another trauma to the ACEs already experienced by children. Retention is likely to undo any potential good that might result from Learning Loss Bridge Camp or the Tennessee Accelerating Literacy and Learning Corps programs.
Contact your Tennessee legislators and ask them to invest in academic supports and interventions for our youngest school children and to leave retention decisions to teachers and parents, where they belong.
Sign up for Latino Tennessee Voices newsletter:Read compelling stories for and with the Latino community in Tennessee.
Sign up for Black Tennessee Voices newsletter:Read compelling columns by Black writers from across Tennessee.
Signed by members of the Tennessee Public Education Coalition.
Josh Anderson-Anderson County
Joe Fink- Anderson County
Terri M. Gilbert- Anderson County
Susan Fowler- Anderson County
Ann Gann- Anderson County
Larry Gann- Anderson County
Lori C. Houck- Anderson County
Marsha Livingston- Anderson County
Liz McGeachy- Anderson County
Carolynne Moss- Anderson County
Robert Moss- Anderson County
Maria Orlando - Anderson County
V. L. Stonecipher - Anderson County
Patsye Thurmon- Anderson County
Karlene Richter- Anderson County
Mary Fell- Anderson County
Florence Plemmons- Anderson County
Theresa Venale- Anderson County
Gloria Caton- Anderson County
Pat Petrie- Anderson County
Diane Alsop- Anderson County
Sandy Christen- Anderson County
Melanie Harles- Anderson County
Miriam Wankerl- Anderson County
Kari Iwanski - Anderson County
Mary Elizabeth Alexander- Anderson County
Patricia H. Aldridge- Blount County
Ginny Ayers- Blount County
Brenda Bell- Blount County
Katy Chiles- Blount County
Douglas Gamble- Blount County
Nina Gregg- Blount County
Dustin Park- Blount County
Lo Starck- Blount County
Marjorie Stewart- Blount County
Dan Lawson- Bradley County
Wm Tom Chadwell-Campbell County
Elena Roser- Cheatham County
Martha Wettemann - Cheatham County
Alesandra Bellos- Davidson County
Caryn Clopton- Davidson County
Pam DeMatteo-Linn- Davidson County
Romy Frank-Davidson County
Amy Frogge- Davidson County
Lucy Kells- Davidson County
Karen McIntyre for Davidson County
Cara Meissner- Davidson County
Jill Speering- Davidson County
Mary Holden- Davidson County
Dr. Sarah Parker- Davidson County
Nancy Stetten- Davidson County
Jack Willey- Davidson County
Pattye Post- Dickson County
Larry Proffit- Dickson County
Jerry Anderson- Greene County
Alison Anderson- Hamilton County
Alysia Comerford- Hamilton County
Allie Beukema- Hamilton County
James Hill- Hamilton County
Amy Packer- Hamilton County
Nathan Packer- Hamilton County
Jane Boyd – Hawkins County
Juanita Mitchell – Hawkins County
Candace Bannister- Knox County
Travis Donoho- Knox County
Dave Gorman- Knox County
Bob Kronick- Knox County
Caroline Mann- Knox County
Lance McCold- Knox County
Jennifer Owen- Knox County
Jane Skinner- Knox County
Jennifer VanTol- Knox County
Douglas E. Veum- Knox County
Olivia Cook- McMinn County
Austin Sauerbrei- McMinn County
Dr. Patricia Waters- McMinn County
Rosa Ponce- Montgomery County
Martha Deadrick- Roane County
Patricia Aramayo- Roane County
Dorothy Jones- Roane County
Darlene Johnson- Roane County
Steven Rogers- Scott County
Jerri Green- Shelby County
Peg Watkins- Shelby County
Carlista Barttels- Sullivan County
Amy Collette- Sullivan County
Charlotte Hoover- Sullivan County
Susan Lodal- Sullivan County
Angelo Pellitteri- Sullivan County
Marsha Pellitteri- Sullivan County
Candace Sass- Sullivan County
Jennifer Schmitz- Sullivan County
Chae Wells- Sullivan County
Roberta Senzer- Sumner County
Vanessa Sheehan- Sumner County
A.H. Trask- Washington County
Mary H. Stewart- Washington County
Ellen Finney- Williamson County
Kent Fourman- Williamson County
Tammy Lipsey- Williamson County
This article originally appeared on Nashville Tennessean: Retaining third-graders will create more trauma for Tennessee students
