Who will sit on Asheville's water outage independent review committee? Here's the vote

Water Resources Director David Melton addresses City Council January 10, 2023 on the timeline of events that led to water outages that impacted thousands in Asheville.
Water Resources Director David Melton addresses City Council January 10, 2023 on the timeline of events that led to water outages that impacted thousands in Asheville.

ASHEVILLE - A Jan. 24 vote by Asheville City Council cemented seven members to its newly-established water outage independent review committee, a nine-person body ultimately responsible for analyzing the events and circumstances that led to the unprecedented holiday outages that impacted thousands and left some without water for days at a time.

Of the about 20 possible candidates, City Council unanimously approved staff's recommendations.

Among them are three public water systems experts, including a former Asheville director of Water Resources, an engineer at the Knoxville Utilities Board and a director of internal development at Highfill Infrastructure Engineering in Charlotte.

Previous coverage:Asheville creates independent review committee in the wake of widespread water outages

Rounding out the Asheville appointees, along with two communications professionals, are area residential and commercial customers.

City Council approved the creation of the third-party independent review committee on Jan. 10.

Assistant City Manager Ben Woody said most of the potential candidates reached out independently, although staff did reach out to some candidates to increase the total number available to council. Staff requested that all potential candidates provide a resume and/or statement of interest.

Assistant City Manager Ben Woody addresses City Council January 10, 2023 on recent water outages.
Assistant City Manager Ben Woody addresses City Council January 10, 2023 on recent water outages.

More:Water outages: Asheville chose to cut off the south from water; Melton made the call

The final two selections will be made by Buncombe County Board of Commission at its Feb. 7 meeting.

Michele Ashley, the city residential customer selected, said in her statement to staff that she is a tenant living in South Asheville, in the newly-developed Hawthorne luxury apartments on Mills Gap Road.

"The experience of our most recent water outage was both a shock, inconvenience (and) a major disruption to my quality oflife as a single woman living in Asheville," Ashley wrote.

Like many Asheville area residents in the wake of the disaster, Ashley said in her nine years living in Asheville, "this by far has been the most disturbing weather crisis yet."

"My personal experience in combination with witnessing a complex of over two hundred units, filled with families and working professionals, resort to various survival mode methods, I believe would provide support and clarity as to how we, as community, can prevent this from happening again," Ashley said in her statement.

Who are the city's picks?

A list of the candidates, along with their resumes, bios and statements when included, can be found here.

Public water supply experts:

  • John McLaughlin, Director of Internal Development at Highfill Infrastructure Engineering; active in publicwater system vulnerability and risk assessment.

  • Ted Tyree, Engineer at Knoxville Utilities Board.

  • Michael Holcombe, Former director of Water Resources for the city of Asheville.

Communications professionals:

  • Mike McGill, President WaterPIO; water system crisis communication consultant; previous chief communications officer for Cape Fear Public Utility.

  • Rob Brisley, U.S. Customs/Border Protection Incident Management Branch Team; Previously employed at N.C. Department of Public Safety as incident management team specialist; Disaster Response Specialist Contractor.

Residential water customer:

  • Michele Ashley, renter; consultant.

Commercial water customer:

  • Carolyn Roy, Owner of Biscuit Head restaurants, whose South Asheville location lost water.

Carolyn Roy, co-founder of Biscuit Head, and cannery manager Walter Hill received Garden & Gun's Made in the South Award in food on Nov. 14, 2022. Roy was chosen to sit on Asheville's water outage independent review committee.
Carolyn Roy, co-founder of Biscuit Head, and cannery manager Walter Hill received Garden & Gun's Made in the South Award in food on Nov. 14, 2022. Roy was chosen to sit on Asheville's water outage independent review committee.

What's the committee's timeline?

City of Asheville water resources crews have hooked a pump up to hydrants in Roger Farmer Memorial Park at 71 Deaverview Road on Dec. 30, 2022.
City of Asheville water resources crews have hooked a pump up to hydrants in Roger Farmer Memorial Park at 71 Deaverview Road on Dec. 30, 2022.

After the county makes its selections, Woody said the committee will likely hold its first meeting in mid- to late-February. Once seated, the committee will engage an expert, begin analysis and share updates to council.

As an independent review committee, Woody said their meetings are not required to be public.

More:ACLU of NC, press advocates petition to release Asheville police reporter arrests bodycam

More:Asheville developer to renovate Montford church in historic district into 6 condos

About 90 days from its establishment, the committee will provide a final written report and presentation to City Council.

The committee will provide:

  • A comprehensive account of the event.

  • An assessment of the city's operations and emergency response and communication efforts.

  • An analysis of needed infrastructure and process and policy changes that, if implemented, would maximize prevention of future events and improve communication, emergency response and mitigation processes.

Included in its list of potential appointments, the city also offered its picks for an independent facilitator and an expert to prepare the report.

Woody said there are no contracts finalized. Though the committee members will be volunteers, funding will come from the Water Resources Fund’s existing budget to contract with an independent facilitator to support the independent review committee and to engage with an expert to prepare a written report.

More:Mission files lawsuit fighting state over Pardee decision, claimed threat of favoritism

Woody said he doesn't yet know how much those contracts will be.

The city's pick for an independent facilitator is Kelley O'Brien, owner of Carrboro-based KTO Strategy and Communications, and an adjunct instructor at the UNC School of Government.

The possible expert is Keith Webb, vice president of McGill Associates, former public water department engineer, and someone with direct experience with Asheville's water system.

Sarah Honosky is the city government reporter for the Asheville Citizen Times, part of the USA TODAY Network. News Tips? Email shonosky@citizentimes.com or message on Twitter at @slhonosky.

This article originally appeared on Asheville Citizen Times: Asheville makes 1st picks for water outage independent review group