How the situation in Brazil boiled over into violence
The burbling political tension in Brazil finally boiled over as supporters of former rightwing President Jair Bolsonaro stormed the country's government buildings in an all-too-familiar scene this weekend. Here's everything you need to know:
What was the build-up to the attack?
Pressure has been mounting in Brazil ever since Bolsonaro lost his re-election bid to challenger Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, known as Lula, in October 2022. While Bolsonaro, a right-wing populist, eventually came to accept his defeat, he made false claims of widespread voter fraud in the months leading up to Lula's Jan. 1, 2023 inauguration.
The allegations were not a new occurrence. Bolsonaro, who came into office in 2019, had spent years spreading misinformation about Brazil's election process, including allegations of fraud and claims that hackers had tried to steal the election from him, The New York Times reports. "Those claims are false, according to Brazil's election officials, fact-checking agencies, and independent election-security experts who have studied the country's electronic voting system," the Times noted. "Yet in speeches, interviews, and hundreds of posts on social media, the president has consistently and methodically repeated those baseless claims and many others about Brazil's voting system."
Fueled on by Bolsonaro's claims, the outgoing president's supporters have been protesting since his loss, continuing after Lula was inaugurated at the beginning of 2023. Even after Bolsonaro left Brazil for the U.S. prior to Lula's swearing-in, the tensions among protesters continued to build.
What happened at the Three Powers Plaza?
In the days leading up to Jan. 8, 2023, Bolsonaro's supporters had been camping out at the Three Powers Plaza in the nation's capital, Brasília. The plaza is home to the key buildings of all three of Brazil's branches of government: the National Congress building, the Supreme Federal Court building, and the Planalto Presidential Palace.
While the protesters had mostly been peaceful, that changed on Jan. 8, when a massive crowd of Bolsonaro supporters stormed all three buildings in an apparent attempt to reinstate the ousted president. Videos from local media obtained by The New York Times and The Associated Press showed the protesters forcing their way into the trifecta of buildings representing Brazil's democracy.
The rioters smashed windows and clambered over barricades to get onto the roofs of the buildings. Footage from inside the buildings showed people making their way through the offices of top officials in the Planalto Palace, as well as ransacking the upper chamber of the National Congress building. In the Supreme Federal Court building, a similar scene took place, with rioters smashing windows and breaking in. The Times additionally reported that the rioters were also attacking journalists and carrying "bladed weapons."
Within a few hours, the Brazilian military reportedly re-took control of the plaza, and hundreds of people were arrested.
How was Brazil's Jan. 8 similar to the Jan. 6 Capitol riot?
As numerous media outlets, including The New York Times, USA Today, and The Washington Post noted, the Brazilian riots draw obvious parallels to the Jan. 6, 2021 attack on the U.S. Capitol, which unfolded in an eerily similar manner and for eerily similar ends.
While the attack in Brazil, unlike the U.S., seemed to target all three branches of government and appeared larger in scope than Jan. 6, the two events seemed to emerge from the same place: a series of falsehoods fanned by Bolsonaro or, in the case of the United States, by former President Donald Trump, about their respective election losses.
"The similarities of Brazilian far-right mobs storming Congress, the Supreme Court, and Presidential Palace with the Jan. 6 insurrection of the Capitol are not coincidental," Robert Muggah, co-founder of the Rio de Janeiro think tank Igarapé Institute, told the Post. "Like their MAGA counterparts, Bolsonaro supporters have been fed a steady diet of misinformation and disinformation for years, much of it modeled on the narratives peddled by far-right influencers in the U.S."
Axios noted how Trump's false claims of widespread voter fraud were echoed for months by Bolsonaro. The latter, unlike Trump, reportedly accepted his defeat early on — though he never conceded the election, allowing his supporters to continue promulgating the lie.
Where does Brazil go from here?
"The protests in Brasília tried to undermine Lula's governability, but in practice, they undermined Bolsonaro's credibility as an opposition leader," Thomas Traumann, a Brazilian journalist, told Americas Quarterly. Brian Winter, the publication's editor-in-chief, agreed, "This was a disaster for Bolsonaro, I think," he wrote. "Given his self-imposed exile in Florida, and relative silence since losing the election, the race to succeed him as the leader of Brazil's conservative movement will now gain even more momentum. Just as Jan. 6 accelerated Trump's decline, we are already seeing opposition figures distance themselves from the former president."
Yes, Brazil's Jan. 8 is "yet another failed attempt by the extreme right to undermine democracy," Valentina Sader, the associate director and Brazil lead at the Adrienne Arsht Latin America Center, told the Atlantic Council, an international affairs think tank. But "amid global trends of declining democratic freedoms and political instability across Latin America and the Caribbean, which country is the next target?"
In The Atlantic, Anne Applebaum made the case that "we should … get ready to help the Brazilian government in its quest for justice. We should help it pursue financial ties, political relationships, or other connections between American and Brazilian insurrectionists, including links between Trump and Bolsonaro, if they are significant" because "democratic revolutions have long been contagious. Now we know that antidemocratic revolutions can be too."
You may also like
Why car sales are falling in the U.S.
Are the rich ruining thrifting?