Sleep All Night Long on These Reddit-Approved Mattresses

"Hearst Magazines and Yahoo may earn commission or revenue on some items through these links."

A good night’s sleep always feels just out of reach no matter how early I get to bed. You can do yoga or listen to sleep podcasts, but often, the best solution is upgrading your sleep essentials—especially if you haven’t replaced your mattress in a decade. Getting new pillows, duvet inserts, and mattress pads all help improve sleep or comfort, but the foundation—your mattress—is what’s most important.

Finding a mattress that works for you is a personal decision that often requires more than just online research or 10 minutes of lying down at a big-box mattress store. It takes experience and real-life recommendations from fervent sleepers and mattress enthusiasts, and you know you can find them on Reddit. We’ve used our expertise to recommend the best mattresses, but when you’re double-checking lofty marketing claims or intel from other sleepers just like you, there’s no replacement for the collective info dump that is Reddit.

We parsed through subreddits like r/mattress, r/buyitforlife, and r/sleep, among others, to find the most common, trustworthy recommendations for the best mattresses Reddit loves. Here are the picks of the masses.

The Best Mattresses According to Reddit

• Best Overall Foam: Saatva Loom & Leaf Mattress

• Most Affordable Foam: Casper Sleep Element Mattress

• Best Mid-Range Foam: Nectar Premier Mattress

• Best for Athletes: Zoma Hybrid Mattress

• Best Hybrid: Purple RestorePremier Hybrid Mattress

What to Consider

Before making your final decision on a new mattress, make sure you pay attention to the type of mattress it is, the firmness, the sizes available, and its long-term durability.

Type

The three major types of mattresses are foam, spring, and hybrid mattresses.

Foam mattresses are made with several layers of dense foam that conforms close to your body as you sleep and provides a sturdy, comfortable platform. Most foam mattresses tend to run slightly warmer than hybrid or spring options, but often have cooling technology built in to account for this. Lots of foam options include several layers of foam, sometimes with different types of foam in each layer, rather than one big block—this is an effort to improve the breathability and firmness of the mattress.

Spring mattresses have interior springs spaced out through the mattress, usually with a padded top for comfort. The springs are often more forgiving than foam mattresses and offer more give when you move around. These mattresses typically distribute air better, leading to a cooler night’s sleep overall. The springs themselves, however, may not distribute your weight and pressure as evenly or comfortably as foam options.

Hybrid mattresses have springs inside, set into a thick layer of foam on to integrate the core features from both types of mattresses. The mix offers slightly more give and breathability than all-foam mattresses without sacrificing the forms-to-your-body nature of foam.

Firmness

Soft mattresses offer more immediate squish as you lie down and can be comforting for many users. Firm mattresses provide more stability and support for your body, so, for folks with sore necks or backs, a firmer mattress may be the right option. There is no universal scale for overall firmness, however most product listings do provide a basic description of the overall firmness of each mattress.

Size

While the size of your mattress largely comes down to how many people are sleeping in the bed and the space you have available in your bedroom, there are some limitations depending on the company you buy from. Make sure to check if your preferred mattress size is an option before making a final decision, whether that’s a California king or a twin XL.

Longevity and Warranty

Mattresses are an investment. You use your mattress every single day, so the cost and overall durability of that mattress reflects its true value over time. Many cheap mattresses do not hold up to long-term use (save for this Casper one, which comes highly recommended on Reddit), while others not only stand up to the test of time, but come with multiyear warranties to guarantee it.

How We Selected

In order to find the best mattresses according to Reddit, we scoured through several subreddits including r/buyitforlife, r/mattress, r/sleep, and many more, looking for discussion threads and reviews from users who gave their own personal experiences and why they love the options they own. We also cross-referenced Reddit’s picks with our own in-house research and testing to make sure we only recommend great mattresses that you (and Reddit) will love.

Loom & Leaf Mattress

This Saatva Loom & Leaf mattress provides a quality mixture of firmness and comfort that sets it apart from many other options, including ones with a higher price tag. The mattress comes in two different firmness levels to fit your own personal preference and the memory-foam layer is designed to disperse your weight and reduce pressure on your back or sides.

“It just has fantastic pressure relief, good contour, and it's the perfect firmness,” says Reddit user and verified mattress tester derek-naplab.

The six-layer design also offers unique comfort that is specialized for mixed use from two partners sharing the bed, so you don’t roll towards the heavier partner during the night.

Sleep Element Mattress

In terms of budget picks, there are few options recommended on Reddit more than the Casper Sleep Element mattress. The mattress has two layers of memory foam for extra support on your back and, more importantly, Reddit users say it’s proven to stand the test of time in spite of its affordable price tag.

“We’ve had a Casper for six or seven years and its condition is the same as the day we bought it,” says roaddog on a post focused on mattress longevity.

The mattress also comes with a removable cover that adds to the overall lifespan of the bed, protecting it from your natural body oils and anything else that could sink into your mattress, like body lotion.

Premier Mattress

The Nectar Premier mattress provides a mix of comfort, support, and firmness that has many Redditors enthralled with it. The mattress has five layers of foam and support to improve overall support and comfort, including a gel-infused layer that reduces the temperature of the bed while you sleep.

“My 18-year-old son has a Nectar mattress. He absolutely loves it. He is a very active person,” says user Nooneatall2122. “He has had it over a year and still brags about how much he would buy another.”

Hybrid Mattress

The Zoma is a unique option because of its design. This hybrid mattress is built for active individuals, with gel foam and convoluted foam to support recovering muscles.

“It takes some time to get used to [the convoluted foam], but well worth it,” says Reddit user exciting-series-9533.

The convoluted foam, a.k.a foam with a patterned texture, on the top layer also improves airflow to prevent the buildup of heat over a full night of sleep. This breathability also extends to the ventilated outer fabric that wicks away moisture throughout the night.

Hybrid Premier Mattress

One of the most expensive yet popular options on the market is the Purple hybrid premier mattress. The mattress is one of many unique options from Purple, which is best known for its grid-style top layer of support. The grid supports and conforms to your body while providing ample space for hot air to escape.

When talking about the movement and feel of the Purple Premier 4, Reddit user southpark says, “The bed transmits almost zero motion while moving around. The top may feel soft, but it’s more supportive than any other mattress I’ve tried regardless of firmness. It’s supportive with give from the grid, but it firms up under you.”

Signature Hybrid Mattress

If you’re looking for support and comfort together, Redditors from around the world recommend the Brooklyn Bedding Signature hybrid. The mattress has all-around appeal with a mid-range price tag and high-quality materials that work well in tandem.

The mattress coils stand independently, so they react directly to your body’s movement for support and pressure relief. Because each coil is separate from the others, it can support your body precisely as you move. Coils connected to each other tend to move and react as a group, which provides less targeted support and creates larger areas of bowing than just coils directly underneath your body.

The three unique layers of memory-foam contour and support your body as it moves throughout the night.

“I recommend them anytime it fits into someone’s budget and requirements,” says user TheApprenticeLife. “If you want a sub-$1,000 bed-in-a-box, it checks all the boxes.”

Tempur-Adapt Medium Hybrid Mattress

Perhaps the most well-known and popular mattress brand on sleep-related Reddit forums, Tempur-Pedic offers several high quality options like this Tempur-Adapt Medium hybrid mattress. The mattress serves as the true middle ground from Tempur-Pedic—it isn’t as firm as the brand’s all-memory-foam options, but it’s more supportive and comfortable than a spring-coil pick.

“I have had the Adapt Medium for about two months now. It does take time to break in. I don’t sink too far in—just the right amount. I mostly sleep on my side, but laying on my back feels best on this mattress,” says Reddit user Kavy777.

The Tempur-Adapt Medium comes with a horde of individual coils that provide active response to your body’s movements and targeted pressure relief for those sore shoulders or hips. The mattress also comes with two unique foam layers that are designed specifically for adaptability to your weight, shape, and body temperature.

You Might Also Like

• The Do’s and Don’ts of Using Painter’s Tape

• The Best Portable BBQ Grills for Cooking Anywhere

• Can a Smart Watch Prolong Your Life?