We need a solution for illegal immigration, but new Texas law isn’t it | Opinion

With the furor over abortion dying down, for now, it had been a few days since a Texas law made national news.

Gov. Greg Abbott took care of that with a high-profile signing of Texas’ latest effort to insert itself into federal immigration matters. The new law creates a state crime of illegal entry and allows judges to order the removal of those who violate it, under certain conditions.

The law has already drawn a court challenge. It’s novel and vague enough that its exact fate is unpredictable, but the supremacy of federal immigration law is clear. Texas is once again meddling where it doesn’t belong. We’re sympathetic to the impulse to address the unprecedented illegal immigration driving this. But attempting to usurp policing of the border isn’t the answer.

Abbott, Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick and Republicans in the Legislature have escalated their battle again and again, spending billions of state dollars and diverting law enforcement in ways that hurt other parts of the state. They’ve stretched the Department of Public Safety and the Texas National Guard. And while they’ve scored victories in terms of optics and raising awareness of the federal failure, it’s debatable whether they’ve made the state much safer.

Critics of this law raise legitimate concerns that it could lead to discriminatory enforcement against Hispanic Texans and increase mistrust of police in vulnerable immigrant communities.

However, they’ve overstated the case, predicting rampant racial profiling and trotting out the tired canard that it’s a “show me your papers” law. In most of Texas, the law will have little effect because of the burden of proof it sets for law enforcement to allege illegal entry. The odds of cases emanating from places like Tarrant County are slim. Even Sheriff Bill Waybourn, no dove on immigration, says he doesn’t expect much effect on his agency.

Along the border, it could be a different story, if DPS officers or local police get zealous. The best way to avoid any of that would be for the federal government to finally tackle the current crisis head-on.

Republicans can’t be the only advocates of reducing illegal immigration. Those prioritizing the prevention of immigration enforcement tragedies should be eager to see change, too, and lean on their allies in the Biden administration to push it. A record backlog has migrants waiting five years for an asylum hearing. That’s not good for them or the nation.

Border security and immigration are part of the annual year-end rush to legislate in Washington. Republicans are demanding significant funding and policy changes in exchange for more U.S. support for Ukraine in its war against Russia. Senate negotiations are dragging, but lawmakers say they’re making progress on a deal to increase deportations once certain thresholds of illegal immigration are passed.

But House Republicans must realize that they can’t hold out for every immigration policy they might want. It’s taken decades for the system to degrade to this level of dysfunction, and it won’t be fixed with slapdash legislation. If GOP lawmakers hold out for a 100% border wall and a return to President Donald Trump’s “Remain in Mexico” policy, they’ll hold up progress that can help now.

Abbott has won the political argument, at least on one front. His tactic of sending migrants to cities with “sanctuary” policies for illegal immigration has forced leaders in those areas to acknowledge the obvious: We cannot absorb huge numbers of immigrants year after year.

In the latest development, Chicago tried to stem the flow by restricting buses. So, Abbott put more than 100 migrants on a plane. Trolling? Yes. The point is driven home again, though.

Texas can’t and shouldn’t police immigration. But the job must be done. Let’s finally get the federal government to do it.

Do you have an opinion on this topic? Tell us!

We love to hear from Texans with opinions on the news — and to publish those views in the Opinion section.

• Letters should be no more than 150 words.

• Writers should submit letters only once every 30 days.

• Include your name, address (including city of residence), phone number and email address, so we can contact you if we have questions.

You can submit a letter to the editor two ways:

• Email letters@star-telegram.com (preferred).

• Fill out this online form.

Please note: Letters will be edited for style and clarity. Publication is not guaranteed. The best letters are focused on one topic.