Senate Plans Virus Bill Vote After Dispute Over Unemployment Aid

Steven T. Dennis, Erik Wasson and Colin Wilhelm

(Bloomberg) -- The Senate is poised to vote Wednesday night on the $2 trillion coronavirus relief package after moving past a last-minute dispute over expanded unemployment benefits for low-wage workers.

Senate aides released the final text less than 30 minutes before the vote was scheduled.

Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin dismissed the objections from four GOP senators and said he still expects the Senate to pass the legislation on Wednesday.

“Our expectation is this bill passes tonight and gets to the House tomorrow and they pass it,” Mnuchin told reporters at the White House.

David Popp, a spokesman for Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, confirmed that the Senate will vote Wednesday.

Read the text of the stimulus bill

Senator Lindsey Graham of South Carolina and several colleagues want to limit the unemployment insurance provisions, warning that, as written, they would damage the economy by providing millions of workers with more money in unemployment benefits than they make on the job.

The GOP Senators want to amend the stimulus package to modify that provision, which has been part of the bill since Sunday. A vote on such an amendment would likely fail, and moving past the issue would likely clear the way to pass the bill and send it to the House.

Graham, Ben Sasse of Nebraska, Rick Scott of Florida and Tim Scott of South Carolina said granting workers an additional $600 per week in unemployment benefits for four months, would give employers an incentive to cut some employees and encourage laid off workers to stay out of the work force. They want to cap jobless insurance at 100% of a laid-off worker’s salary.

“This bill pays you more not to work than if you were working,” Graham said, adding it would provide the equivalent of $24.07 an hour in his state to laid-off workers. The minimum wage in the state is $7.25 an hour.

He said that would “destroy what’s left of the economy.”

Mnuchin said the flat $600 per week “was the only we could ensure the stated could get money quickly and in a fair way,” since it would take too long to tailor benefits to a person’s most recent salary. He said he had spoken with the Republican senators about their concerns and that he expects the vote to go ahead.

“I don’t think it’ll create incentives,” Mnuchin said. “Most Americans what they want is they want to keep their jobs.”

In response to the objections from the GOP senators, Sanders, a candidate for the Democratic presidential nomination, tweeted that he’d hold up the bill and insist on more strings on money for corporations unless they drop their concerns.

“Unless Republican senators drop their objections to the coronavirus legislation, I am prepared to put a hold on this bill until stronger conditions are imposed on the $500 billion corporate welfare fund,” Sanders tweeted.

A spokesperson for Senate Finance Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley, an Iowa Republican and one of the primary negotiators of the provision, rejected the GOP senators’ arguments.

“Nothing in this bill incentivizes businesses to lay off employees, in fact it’s just the opposite,” Taylor Foy said in an email to Bloomberg News. “The goal all along has been, first and foremost, to help businesses make payroll so employers don’t have to lay off employees, and to ensure that there’s a robust unemployment insurance program to help those who have lost their jobs.”

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said the jobless benefit wouldn’t create an incentive for workers to leave their jobs. “You can’t just quit and say I’m going on unemployment,” she said on PBS.

“The Democrats, Republicans and the White House are in agreement that we should have this $600 payment,” she said, in part because it’s too complicated to create a different payment level for each state.

Senate Standoff

Democratic Senator Chris Murphy of Connecticut ripped the push to shrink the benefit for lower-wage workers.

“Let’s not over-complicate this. Several Republican senators are holding up the bipartisan Coronavirus emergency bill because they think the bill is too good for laid off Americans.”

The $600-per-week flat rate boost in jobless benefits was a compromise reached by Senate Republican and Democratic negotiators, as well as the Trump administration.

Some of the people involved in the talks had worried that capping the temporarily increased unemployment benefits to workers’ previous earnings would be too technically difficult and significantly delay money for individuals at the height of the virus-driven economic shock.

The across-the-board increase was intended to “deliver needed aid in a timely manner rather than burning time to create a different administrative regime for each state,” Foy said.

He added that the Senate was still trying to vote on Wednesday night and working on a possible regulatory fix with the Department of Labor.

For more articles like this, please visit us at

Subscribe now to stay ahead with the most trusted business news source.

©2020 Bloomberg L.P.