I Can’t Figure Out Who Secretly Has 6 Toes On ‘Bachelor in Paradise’

Korin Miller
Photo credit: John Fleenor - Getty Images

From Women's Health

  • Bachelor in Paradise is currently in its sixth season.
  • Last night, Demi Burnett found a footprint in the sand that has six toes.

Watching Bachelor in Paradise is the gift that keeps on giving. First, Caelynn Miller-Keyes accused Blake Horstmann of treating her like a “dirty little secret” after they hooked up at a music festival before the show started. Then, Blake started pursuing practically everything that moves, and then there’s the whole love triangle between Hannah Goodwin, Blake, and Dylan Barbour.

Well, now there’s a mystery on set, and it’s everything. ICYMI: At the end of last night’s episode, Demi Burnett found a footprint in the sand that has six toes. “Who is the monster running around here with six toes?” she asked out loud. (Never mind that a producer probably pointed it out to her first, because who sits around counting toes in footprints in the sand?) This is huge.

Now, everyone is freaking out about who could be the six-toed wonder on BiP. Demi, for what it’s worth, thinks it’s Blake. That said, Blake totally injured his toe on a rock earlier in the episode and there was no mention of him having more than the usual toe count. That doesn’t mean it can’t be him, but…just saying.

Naturally, speculation is at an all-time high on Twitter.

Shockingly, Reality Steve has not yet weighed in on the controversy.

Clearly, there’s a lot happening in Paradise—the totally clueless Cam Ayala is obsessed with Caelynn, who is feeling national treasure Mike Johnson, Dylan keeps getting upset because everyone wants Hannah, and Katie broke down in sobs when Wills tried to profess his feelings for her.

And then there’s the toe thing, of course. For the record, there’s nothing wrong with having six toes, and whoever is the six-toed contestant shouldn’t feel ashamed or weird about it. But still…WHO IS IT?!?!

We will keep this post updated as news continues to break on this front.

You Might Also Like