Tiffany's new smile: Shooting survivor gets new teeth thanks to Cape dentist, SWFL donors

Fourteen years later, shooting survivor Tiffany Nemec is smiling again — all thanks to a Cape Coral dentist and a generous Southwest Florida.

The North Fort Myers woman lost about half her teeth in 2008, when her jealous ex-boyfriend tracked her down and shot her in the face with a shotgun. Since then, most of her remaining teeth had slowly broken and fallen out.

Nemec couldn’t afford dental implants. But after years of searching, she found someone willing to do the surgery for almost no cost: Cape Coral dentist Mauricio Martinez.

Martinez and his team at Gulf Coast Smiles finally gave Nemec back her smile on Thursday, Aug. 11.

Tiffany Nemec took a selfie of her new smile, soon after getting dental implants on Thursday, Aug. 11. The North Fort Myers woman has a full smile for the first time 2008, when her jealous ex-boyfriend shot her in the face with a shotgun.
Tiffany Nemec took a selfie of her new smile, soon after getting dental implants on Thursday, Aug. 11. The North Fort Myers woman has a full smile for the first time 2008, when her jealous ex-boyfriend shot her in the face with a shotgun.

'I was crying. It's overwhelming': A shooting survivor asked for help, and SWFL responded

More: A shotgun blast destroyed her teeth. Now a Cape Coral dentist is helping her smile again.

Nemec, 34, said she’s still in a lot of pain from the all-day procedure and can’t talk much, but she’s thrilled to be able to smile again after all this time.

“I’m so happy!” she said in a text message. “I’m in so much pain, but I have never been so happy! The pain is a million times worth it!

“Everyone who has seen them has told me how great they look and how amazing I look with them!”

Martinez removed what was left of Nemec’s teeth — mostly broken-off tooth roots left below the gumline — and replaced them with brand-new dental implants.

It’s typically a $45,000-$60,000 procedure, he said in May. But he donated his services, and the companies that make the implants and the surgical guide needed to place those implants donated those, too.

Tiffany Nemec smiles at her son Dallas, 8, in their North Fort Myers home on Monday, May 2, 2022.
Tiffany Nemec smiles at her son Dallas, 8, in their North Fort Myers home on Monday, May 2, 2022.

“She’s been trying to get help and nobody’s been either able or willing,” Martinez said in May. “... And if we have the ability to help her and better her life, than why not do that for her?”

All Nemec needed to do was raise $3,000 for the anesthesiologist — a goal she more than met after a May 13 News-Press story about her situation. Southwest Florida donors eventually gave $8,000 to her GoFundMe page. And then about $20,000 more in cash, checks and credit-card donations flooded a separate fund at Gulf Coast Smiles.

Martinez got involved after he and his wife, Julie Martinez, saw a TV news report last year about Nemec’s situation. And they decided right then to help her.

“My wife just turns to me,” he said in May. “And she says, ‘You’ve gotta do something for this lady.’”

Julie Martinez said she was at Gulf Coast Smiles during the surgery, and she was happy to finally see it happening.

“I was just so, so excited!” she said.

Tiffany Nemec has lived with pain, PTSD and depression since she was shot in the face and abdomen by her abuser 14 years ago. She is hopeful that her upcoming dental reconstructive surgery will help restore her smile and relive some of her pain. She has had trouble eating in the last year because her teeth that were damaged in the shooting have gotten so painful. She needs to raise $3,000 to cover the anesthesia bill.

Everyone at the dental practice was in a great mood on surgery day, she said. “I think she touched a lot of people’s hearts … They were just excited to help and be part of it. Just to give her something to smile about and know that there are still good people in the world.”

Nemec said she’s grateful to Martinez and everyone involved for making the surgery happen.

“To say I’m grateful would be a gross understatement!” she said in a text. “I love the Martinez family and all the staff at Gulf Coast Smiles! Everyone has been so good to me.”

Connect with this reporter: Charles Runnells is an arts and entertainment reporter for The News-Press and the Naples Daily News. Email him at crunnells@gannett.com or connect on Facebook (facebook.com/charles.runnells.7), Twitter (@charlesrunnells) and Instagram (@crunnells1).

This article originally appeared on Fort Myers News-Press: SW FL shooting survivor gets new teeth from Cape Coral dentist