Trump impeachment: Republicans say they want to expunge record if they retake the House

Clark Mindock
Chief Justice John Roberts arrives for the final impeachment vote in Donald Trump's trial: AP

Republicans are reportedly plotting a way to expunge Donald Trump’s impeachment should they regain control of the House of Representatives in 2020.

The idea comes on the heels of a months long process that Democrats began last year in the House, and has now led to the acquittal of Mr Trump after he became the third president to be impeached in US history.

Now, though, after being taunted by House speaker Nancy Pelosi that “impeachment lasts forever”, it appears that minority leader Kevin McCarthy wants to rewrite history should he take the gavel from the Democratic leader.

“This is the fastest, weakest, most political impeachment in history,” he told the New York Post, echoing a talking point he and other Republicans have used previously nearly word-for-word.

He continued: “I don’t think it should stay on the books.”

The comments came just before the Senate voted to acquit Mr Trump on both articles of impeachment he faced, with just one senator breaking ranks during the vote, Mitt Romney.

It is not clear that expunging Mr Trump’s impeachment will have much impact, according to constitutional law experts. While there may be some precedent — Republicans have noted that the House voted to expunge the censure of Andrew Jackson in 1837 — experts say any effort on that front would be largely symbolic.

“There’s nothing in the Constitution that provides for a procedure of expungement,” James Gardner, a law professor at the State University of New York at Buffalo, told The Independent.

“It would be of no significance. Certainly of no legal significance,” Mr Gardner said. “It might be of political significance.”

Should the president’s record be expunged during the next Congress, it would likely mean that he also won re-election in the coming November elections.

Republicans have also promised to immediately begin impeachment proceedings against Joe Biden should be elected president.

Read more

Mitt Romney will vote to convict Trump

Trump’s State of the Union address derided as ‘manifesto of mistruths’

Key swing-vote senator votes to acquit Trump

Trump to face Pelosi ‘for first time in months’ at State of the Union