Twitter users vote Elon Musk out as CEO: Poll

Yahoo Finance Live anchors discuss Elon Musk's latest Twitter poll findings that voted him out as the platform's CEO.

Video Transcript

[AUDIO LOGO]

BRIAN SOZZI: Stay on all things weird here to kick off this week. The people have spoken, an Elon Musk Twitter poll closed this morning, where he asked users over the weekend whether or not he should step down as the CEO of the platform. Promising he'll abide by the results.

Well, the results are in, folks. And Musk has a history of following through on Twitter polls. You can see the result of that poll. Overwhelming amount of Twitter users, 17.5 million votes on this say that he should step down as Twitter.

Now, we're seeing Tesla shares pop in reaction in the premarket. Sentiment is clear, Tesla investors want to see a more focused Elon Musk. And that might mean that he has to just hand over the reins to someone else at Twitter, whoever that might be.

BRAD SMITH: He has a history of following through on Twitter polls. But not all of it is directly because of the result of the poll itself. Some of it is premeditated and already a decisive course of action that, perhaps, he's already mulled over and has decided himself to take even before presenting it to the public. Some of that has been share sales in the past or even, you know, just making different upgrades to some of the different technology within Tesla vehicles.

But for Tesla shareholders, they have been upset by about how much of a headwind that this has proven to be. Just the amount of time and the spectacle of Twitter.

BRIAN SOZZI: And just quickly here, this is not-- unlike-- this is unlikely to happen today. This guy just spent $44 billion to buy an asset like this. In an ideal case, he will have laid out a framework, some form of management framework to who could lead this company. I wouldn't expect to see an SEC release at some point today saying he's stepping down as Twitter. I mean, I can't-- I couldn't imagine.

JULIE HYMAN: He wouldn't have to put out an SEC release, remember?

BRIAN SOZZI: Well, he would have to put out something.

JULIE HYMAN: It's a private company.

BRIAN SOZZI: OK. I'm on [INAUDIBLE]

JULIE HYMAN: He doesn't have to do anything. That's the joy of-- the joy and pain-- he would not have to file with the FCC for a management change because--

BRIAN SOZZI: Isn't their debt publicly traded? The debt.

JULIE HYMAN: I don't think you-- I don't think you would have to file.

BRIAN SOZZI: Fair point.

JULIE HYMAN: I don't think-- I don't think he would. He would probably tweet about it. Listen, you know, he's not gonna put a pull out there unless he wants to do it. It's not like he's leaving it up to the users of Twitter whether he's gonna step down or not.

You know, is he maybe polling the Tesla board or maybe they're pushing him in a particular direction? Maybe. I mean, we don't know what's happening behind closed doors there.

BRIAN SOZZI: Well, he can't do anything at Twitter. I don't he could transform the platform if he has his investments at Tesla continuing to be under pressure. I mean, the stock is down before this. 23% in December alone. 65% year-to-date. Anything that he wants to do at Twitter is going to be funded by his investments in Tesla, which have lost massive value.

JULIE HYMAN: Well, and he keeps saying he's not gonna sell any more shares. And then he keeps selling--

BRIAN SOZZI: He keeps selling shares.

JULIE HYMAN: --more shares because of what's going on at Twitter as well. There are-- there is some analyst commentary, by the way, out today. Even before that poll, it looks like this preceded that, that Oppenheimer is downgrading the stock to perform because of Twitter and because of the risks over at Twitter.

A friend of the show, Colin Rusch, over there, coming out and saying, "He's increasingly isolated as the steward of Twitter's finances with his user management on the platform." That is what he is saying of Musk.

And that there is a "negative feedback loop from departures of Twitter advertisers and users due to inconsistent standards. That results in these increased financing needs that may lead to incremental Tesla sales." Just as there is a more competitive environment right now for Tesla. In other words, the timing is not great for Elon Musk to be getting so enmeshed in Twitter.

BRIAN SOZZI: Comes after Goldman last week, too. Cautious comments as well on Tesla.

BRAD SMITH: And there was also the report from DealBook that you pointed out earlier this morning, Julie, which pointed out-- or talked about Senator Elizabeth Warren and what she may be taking aim at, most notably with regard to where Musk's actions recently have been shortchanging Tesla. And then additionally talking about the series of conflicts of interest with misappropriation of resources from Tesla. Of course, the electric carmaker he also runs.

But for misappropriation or even conflicts of interest in the past, that has been something that has followed Elon Musk around. Even since the acquisition that Tesla made of SolarCity, an entity that he cofounded with his cousin.

So with all of that in mind, I think even as you get more of in DC, more of the Congressional kind of focus in on what's taking place, the alignment of his time and his responsibilities because he still does have a fiduciary interest to shareholders over at Tesla, too.

And so that appropriation of time is a considerable effort for someone who's kind of painted themselves as not just the CEO and the CTO, but also the chief marketing officer of Tesla. When you have that much power over a brand, that's also something that investors recognize, too.

BRIAN SOZZI: Why can't he employ something-- or maybe he should be looking at something like Berkshire Hathaway where he appoints CEOs of all his different businesses and he just serves as an executive chairman. I know he's still a young guy, he likes to be in the trenches, but why wouldn't something like that work here? It might. He just-- I don't know if he's thinking about that.

JULIE HYMAN: Because he doesn't do anything other than what he wants to do. Like, is there any other model? Like, if you look-- you know, that would suggest that he--

BRIAN SOZZI: Not that I've seen. I've never seen any [INAUDIBLE].

JULIE HYMAN: Right, exactly. So who the hell knows.

BRIAN SOZZI: Yeah.

JULIE HYMAN: At the end of the day, that's the bottom line when it comes to Elon Musk.

Advertisement