By Carey Gillam (Reuters) - A U.S. appeals court ruled on Thursday that federal regulators erred in allowing an insecticide developed by Dow AgroSciences onto the market, canceling its approval and giving environmentalists a major victory. The ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, in San Francisco, is significant for commercial beekeepers and others who say a dramatic decline in bee colonies needed to pollinate key food crops is tied to widespread use of a class of insecticides known as neonicotinoids. Critics say the Environmental Protection Agency is failing to evaluate the risks thoroughly. The lawsuit was filed in 2013 against the EPA by organizations representing the honey and honey beekeeping industry. The groups specifically challenged EPA approval of insecticides containing sulfoxaflor, saying studies have shown they are highly toxic to honey bees. The court said in its ruling that sulfoxaflor is a neonicotinoid subclass. Dow AgroSciences, a unit of Dow Chemical Co, first sought EPA approval for sulfoxaflor in 2010 for use in three products. Brand names include Transform and Closer. "It's a complete victory for the beekeepers we represent," said Greg Loarie, an attorney who represents the American Honey Producers Association, the American Beekeeping Federation and other plaintiffs in the case. "The EPA has not been very vigilant." Dow said in a statement that it "respectfully disagrees" with ruling and will "work with EPA to implement the order and to promptly complete additional regulatory work to support the registration of the products." The EPA said it was reviewing the court's decision and would have no further comment. California's Department of Pesticide Regulation issued a statement Thursday noting that it has long had concerns about sulfoxaflor's impact on bees and has never allowed unconditional registration in that key farming state. Honeybees pollinate plants that produce roughly a quarter of the food consumed by Americans. The demise of the bees has become a hotly debated topic between agrichemical companies, which say the insecticides they sell are not to blame, and those who say research shows a direct connection between neonicotinoids and large bee die-offs. The White House has formed a task force to study the issue and the EPA has said it is trying to address concerns. In its ruling, the court found that the EPA relied on "flawed and limited data" to approve the unconditional registration of sulfoxaflor, and that approval was not supported by "substantial evidence." Dow had asked the EPA to approve sulfoxaflor for use on a variety of crops, including citrus, cotton, canola, strawberries, soybeans and wheat. The EPA analyzed studies and data provided by Dow about the effects of sulfoxaflor on various species, including bees, and initially proposed several conditions on approval due to insufficient data provided by Dow, the court found. However, in May 2013 the EPA decided to go ahead with unconditional registration even though the record revealed Dow never completed additional requested studies, the ruling stated. In vacating the EPA approval, the court said that "given the precariousness of bee populations, leaving the EPA’s registration of sulfoxaflor in place risks more potential environmental harm than vacating it." The EPA must obtain further data regarding the effects of sulfoxaflor on bees as required by EPA regulations before it grants approval, the court said. The U.S. Department of Agriculture said earlier this year that losses of managed honeybee colonies hit 42.1 percent from April 2014 through April 2015, up from 34.2 percent for 2013-14, and the second-highest annual loss to date. Agrichemical companies that sell neonicotinoid products say mite infestations and other factors are the cause of bee demise. (Reporting by Carey Gillam in Kansas City, Missouri; Editing by Dan Grebler and Lisa Shumaker)
Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting
- Fort Worth Star-Telegram
The creature was found after a Crime Stoppers tip.
- In The Know by Yahoo
Little boy has sweetest reaction when he spots parents in audience: ‘Proof that being present can make a big difference’
His whole face changed the second he saw them, and the footage is going viral.
- Kansas City Star
”I just wish I could do what I want without getting attacked every week,” tweeted Brittany Matthews, co-owner of Kansas City Current and fiancee of Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes.
Prince William Cheers on Prince George at His Weekend Soccer Game (and Fans Can’t Believe How Tall He Is)
While Prince William and Kate Middleton have many duties to fulfill as royals , they also enjoy their role as parents to three...
- E! News
Evan Marriott became an overnight TV sensation when he starred on the 2003 dating series Joe Millionaire. Scroll on to see what he's up to now.
- Footwear News
Britney Spears Dances in Yellow Target Bikini and Unexpected Heels With an Empowering Body-Confident Message
Spears danced on Instagram in a yellow Target bikini, paired with brown pointed-toe pumps.
- Associated Press
State Sen. Lauren Book often has told the story about how she was sexually abused by her nanny for six years when she was a child. “Truth be told, if it weren’t for my children, I would have ended my life,” she said.
- The Independent
‘I can’t breathe again. I really regret not getting my vaccine,’ Christian Cabrera, 40, texted his brother before his death
- The Daily Beast
Facebook/Alicia WittA month after her parents’ shock deaths from hypothermia, actor Alicia Witt took to Facebook Tuesday to detail how the preventable tragedy has left her reeling and struggling with what she could have done to save them. In a raw statement released Tuesday, the 1984 Dune actor and Orange Is the New Black star wrote that “i had no idea that their heat had gone out. i will never understand how or why they made the choice not to tell me this, not to let me help them with this. my
- Rams Wire
As if Matthew Stafford's game-saving bomb to Cooper Kupp wasn't amazing enough, this camera angle makes it that much better
- Detroit Free Press
Kelly Stafford addressed the relationship between former Detroit Lions teammates Matthew Stafford and Ndamukong Suh, after a play during Rams-Bucs.
It’s no secret that Prince Harry is seeking a judicial review after his security request in the U.K. was denied . However, there’s a...
- Cowboys Wire
"The one that got away" for owner Jerry Jones is now kind of sort of off the hook. Right when the Jones is frowning his face at his current fish's aroma. | From @CdBurnett7
- Bills Wire
What Sean McDermott said about #Bills' kickoff with 13 seconds left vs. #Chiefs:
Did the Bucs just lose their quarterback, too?
- The Wrap
Peter Dinklage Calls Out Disney’s ‘Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs’ Remake: ‘What the F– Are You Doing?’
It's 'f---ing backwards,' according to the 'Game of Thrones' star
- Eating Well
The latest Inside Trader Joe's podcast episode revealed this year's winners of the brand's 13th annual Customer Choice Awards.
- Yahoo Entertainment
Even Pat Sajak was surprised by the first thing the contestant asked for following the celebratory confetti.
- The Telegraph
Nick Kyrgios flirted with disaster in his latest crowd-pleasing doubles victory alongside close friend Thanasi Kokkinakis. In only the fourth game of their quarter-final, Kyrgios smacked a loose ball away in such a dangerous manner that it cannoned into the body of a young boy.
When I was a journalist for The Times (London) in Moscow in December 1992, I saw a print-out of a speech by the then Russian foreign minister, Andrei Kozyrev, warning that if the West continued to attack vital Russian interests and ignore Russian protests, there would one day be a dangerous backlash. As he stated in his speech, his anxiety about Western behavior was rooted in fear that the resulting backlash would destroy liberalism in Russia and Russian co-operation with the West. The point about this history is that the existing crisis with Russia has origins that go far beyond Putin.