By Jonathan Stempel NEW YORK (Reuters) - A federal appeals court on Friday revived an effort to block a New York City regulation that requires people who perform a Jewish circumcision ritual on infants that involves oral suction to first obtain parental consent. A unanimous panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said a trial judge had been too deferential to the city, which had linked the ritual to a deadly form of herpes, in rejecting a request by rabbinical groups for a preliminary injunction. The three-judge panel directed U.S. District Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald in Manhattan to instead use "strict scrutiny" to see if the regulation infringed the plaintiffs' free exercise of religion, violating the First Amendment. At issue was the ritual metzitzah b'peh (MBP), in which a mohel who performs a circumcision uses oral suction to draw blood away from a wound on an infant's penis. The procedure is sometimes performed in ultra-Orthodox communities. In September 2012, the New York City Board of Health voted to require mohels to obtain advance consent in which parents acknowledged the risk of herpes infection linked to the ritual. This came after city health officials identified 11 cases since 2000 in which infant boys contracted herpes simplex virus (HSV) following circumcisions believed to involve oral suction. Two of the boys died. The Central Rabbinical Congress of the United States and Canada, the International Bris Association and some rabbis sought to halt enforcement, but Buchwald denied the request, saying the regulation addressed "legitimate societal concerns." Circuit Judge Debra Ann Livingston, however, wrote for the 2nd Circuit that the regulation was not neutral toward religion because it "purposefully singles out religious conduct performed by a subset of Orthodox Jews," and applies exclusively to them. As a result she said Buchwald should have not reviewed simply whether there was a rational basis for the regulation. "The Department (of Health) may have legitimate reasons for addressing HSV infection risk among infants primarily, if not exclusively, by regulating MBP," Livingston wrote. "On the present record, however, the plaintiffs have made a sufficient case for strict scrutiny by establishing that the risk of transmission by reason of metzitzah b'peh has been singled out." The 2nd Circuit did not rule on the regulation's constitutionality. The city's law department had no comment on the decision. In a joint statement, the plaintiffs called the decision a "great victory," and said they remain ready to work with city officials "to protect our children's health while fully respecting and accommodating our religious practice." The case is Central Rabbinical Congress of the United States and Canada et al v. New York City Department of Health & Mental Hygiene et al, 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 13-107. (Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York, editing by Tom Brown and Andrew Hay)
- AZCentral | The Arizona Republic
Cochise County supervisors are holding out on certifying voters' election results, which would help Democrats, and Katie Hobbs is fighting them.
- The State
Clarrissa Winchester died Nov. 9 when she was seven months pregnant. The baby died as well.
- Kansas City Star
She was found dead in the trunk of a vehicle being driven by her girlfriend in Michigan, state police say.
The Utah senator responded to the former president's meeting with Kanye West and white supremacist Nick Fuentes.
- Business Insider
Trump Org. rests case on sour note in NY tax fraud trial after judge scolds defense over 11th-hour evidence dump
Trump's real-estate company rested its defense case in a Manhattan tax fraud trial, after getting scolded by the judge for an 11th-hour evidence dump.
- NBC Sports Chicago
NBC Sports Chicago's predictions for the free agent destinations of top shortstops such as Trea Turner and Carlos Correa as well as Aaron Judge, Willson Contreras and even Jason Heyward.
- Broncos Wire
Denver's 1st-round pick that was sent to Seattle keeps getting higher, and the team's pick from San Fran (via Miami) keeps getting lower.
- Fox News
After Virginia Rep. Donald McEachin died Monday following a battle with cancer, the new Congress will begin with a vacancy until there is a special election.
Financial experts break down what you need to earn to afford a median-priced home in the United States.
Duchess Fergie Is Invited to Christmas at Sandringham for the First Time Since Her Toe-Sucking Scandal
Duchess Sarah Ferguson (aka Fergie) has been invited to have Christmas with the royals in Sandringham after a 30-year ban.
- Golf Channel
There are a few steps that need to happen before Tiger Woods can envision any sort of peace talks.
- LA Times
As his father drove from California toward Nevada, repeating prayers while wearing a football helmet, a 12-year-old boy made an emergency call from the passenger seat, telling dispatchers he was concerned about his safety.
- Fox News
Donna D’Errico rocks red silk lingerie as former 'Baywatch' star gets into holiday spirit with OnlyFans shoot
The ex "Baywatch" actress, 54, posed in her bedroom while wearing a strappy red bra with matching bottoms for a "Cyber Monday" snap shared on social media.
- The Daily Beast
Photo Illustration by Thomas Levinson/The Daily Beast/GettyABUJA, Nigeria—Russia’s infamous Wagner Group is freeing hardened rebels held in jail cells in the Central African Republic and deploying them overseas, including in Ukraine’s eastern Donbas region, two senior military officers in CAR told The Daily Beast.According to the sources in CAR, where armed rebels have controlled large parts of the country for about a decade, dozens of men held in military and police custody for crimes such as r
The legal hits just keep on coming for Chris and Roberta Laundrie. Brian Laundrie’s parents just lost another legal request ahead of their trial with Gabby Petito’s parents. According to WATE.com, Judge Hunter W. Carroll denied the Laundrie’s motion to limit the scope of their depositions in the lawsuit filed by Joe Petito and Nichole […]
- Rutgers Wire
Paul Finebaum gives his four teams for the College Football Playoff.
- KFSN – Fresno
Authorities have arrested a Fresno businessman accused of defrauding investors and the government of more than $4.2 million.
- The Telegraph
“What didn’t you do to bury me?,” the Duchess of Sussex has asked as she signed off the final episode of her podcast series with a pointed quote.
- NBC Sports BayArea
Mike McDaniel and Kyle Shanahan will face off for the first time as opposing head coaches in Week 13 when the 49ers host the Miami Dolphins on Sunday at Levi's Stadium.
The saga of “traditional marriage” goes on as Candace Cameron Bure unfollows her co-star Jodie Sweetin who decided to step into the chat and seemingly take sides. Candace Cameron Is On A Mission The actress made it clear she will not waver when it comes to her values and there is nothing wrong with standing […]