By David Ingram and Mica Rosenberg NEW YORK (Reuters) - A grand jury decision not to indict a New York policeman over a fatal chokehold underscores how difficult it is to charge an officer in the United States, even when the tactic appears to contradict police department policy and is caught on video. Although Wednesday's decision caught some Americans by surprise, indictments of police officers for excessive force are extremely rare for political, cultural and legal reasons. U.S. courts have ruled that officers should have wide latitude to use physical force to defend themselves or to take suspects into custody. "What's so shocking about this grand jury decision for most folks is that the evidence on the videotape seemed so clear, but grand jurors will very often give the police officers the benefit of the doubt," said Vincent Warren, executive director of the Center for Constitutional Rights. "They treat them not as a citizens but as super citizens." It was not known precisely why the grand jury in Staten Island, one of New York City's five boroughs, decided against indicting Daniel Pantaleo, the white officer whose chokehold was cited by medical examiners as the primary cause in the death of unarmed African American Eric Garner in July. Grand juries generally operate in secret. It was not known even what charges this one considered bringing against Pantaleo, although lawyers not connected to the case said the potential counts likely included manslaughter, at least. It is rare for potential defendants to testify in grand jury proceedings but prosecutors have discretion deciding which witnesses to call and can choose to put a police officer accused of misconduct on the stand. The decision not to indict echoed a similar finding last month by a grand jury in St. Louis County, Missouri, which declined to indict a police officer, Darren Wilson, in the shooting death of Michael Brown. NATIONWIDE PROTESTS The officers in both cases were white, while both men they killed were unarmed African Americans, fueling nationwide protests over race relations and excessive police force. Pantaleo, who is on suspension, said in a statement he never meant to harm anyone and felt very bad about Garner's death. He and other officers tackled Garner, a 43-year-old father of six, on a sidewalk on July 17, and Pantaleo put Garner in a chokehold. Unlike in Brown's death, someone captured the episode on video. Garner died shortly afterward. The city's medical examiner ruled the death a homicide, meaning that the death was caused by another person. The term does not imply intent, a key legal factor. Convicting someone of the most serious charges, such as murder, generally requires proving intent to commit a crime. Less serious charges might require proving only criminal negligence or recklessness. The New York Police Department's patrol manual bans chokeholds, calling them dangerous, but even if the department finds that Pantaleo violated policy, whether or not someone broke police procedure does not mean it is criminal. Pantaleo might be held legally responsible in other ways. The U.S. Justice Department said it would investigate whether Garner's civil rights were violated, and Garner's family could sue the police department for wrongful death or alleged civil rights violations. Police have yet to say whether they will take any disciplinary action. SUPREME COURT STANDARD The U.S. Supreme Court laid out a standard for when police may use excessive force in 1989, in a civil lawsuit about a diabetic man who said he was injured during a roadside stop. The court ruled the amount of force must be reasonable under the circumstances, such as whether a suspect resists arrest, but it also said reasonableness should be judged from the perspective of an officer on the scene, not from hindsight. "Police officers are often forced to make split-second judgments - in circumstances that are tense, uncertain, and rapidly evolving - about the amount of force that is necessary in a particular situation," the court ruled in an opinion written by then-Chief Justice William Rehnquist. The job of a grand jury is to determine whether probable cause exists that someone committed a crime, but Bennett Gershman, a former prosecutor with the Manhattan District Attorney's office, said that in his experience, the prosecutor sets the direction of a grand jury by deciding what evidence the jurors see. He added that prosecutors have incentives not to antagonize police officers and their unions, because they work with police officers daily on cases and because state prosecutors in the United States generally must stand for election. Sometimes prosecutors bring charges and then lose police-violence cases at trial. In one case from the fallout of Hurricane Katrina, a jury in December 2013 acquitted a New Orleans police officer whom prosecutors accused of shooting a man in the back as the man ran away. In 2008, a jury acquitted a Michigan sheriff's deputy of federal civil rights charges after a man died in a struggle with officers. (Reporting by David Ingram and Mica Rosenberg; Editing by Howard Goller)
Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting
Best of both worlds.
"My experiences in the ICU these past weeks have left me surprised, disheartened, but most of all, angry."
The Keeping Up with the Kardashians alum put her most famous asset on display in new Instagram photos
- The Guardian
A newly released memo shows that Trump told the acting attorney general: ‘Just say the election was corrupt [and] leave the rest to me and the [Republican] congressmen’ ‘Make no mistake: this was an attempted coup.’ Photograph: Shannon Stapleton/Reuters We’ve become so inured to Donald Trump’s proto-fascism that we barely blink an eye when we learn that he tried to manipulate the 2020 election. Yet the most recent revelation should frighten every American to their core. On Friday, the House over
A Canadian diver who scored a 0 with a feet-first flop with the finals on the line said she wasn't going to give up
Pamela Ware scored a zero at the Olympics with a failed dive, but she chalked it up to a bad mistake at the worst time.
- Women's Health
“Do you need a pool boy? I’m available."
Improper fuel level detected in postrace inspection for Vettel's Aston Martin.
- In The Know
Woman allegedly catches her neighbor's disturbing behavior outside her window: 'Pretty sure this is illegal'
She said this is why she keeps her curtains closed.
- The Guardian
US viewers have been able to see everything at any given moment while understanding fundamentally nothing about what’s going on The women’s 100m final was a brilliant spectacle but you might have had to wait to watch it. Photograph: Dylan Martinez/Reuters If there’s one message the Olympics unfailingly conveys, it’s that elite competition is all about making the right choices. At a certain point every athlete needs to make the decision not to do certain things: the fencer lunging for the head ra
It was difficult for American Rai Benjamin to comprehend how he ended up finishing second best despite running a massive half a second inside the existing world record in the men's 400 metres hurdles final at the Tokyo Olympics on Tuesday. Norway's Karsten Warholm destroyed his own world record of 46.70 seconds with a breathtaking 45.94 to take gold but he would probably give a bit of credit to Benjamin for pushing him to such an extraordinary feat. Benjamin took silver for the U.S. in 46.17 after staying neck-and-neck with Warholm going into the final straight.
A review of the process by which the Yankees ended up with Andrew Heaney, courtesy of sources directly involved, provides a window into how much more difficult it is to solve a problem at the trade deadline than it is to identify one.
Costco, Kroger, Target, Walmart and Apple change mask policies, as CDC warns about rise in delta variant
The agency now recommends that people, regardless of vaccination status, wear face masks indoors again in certain situations.
Suni Lee failed to win gold on the uneven bars and blamed the 'mess up' on spending too much time on social media
The individual all-around champion vowed to stay off social media so she could focus on her next Olympics event, but she's continued to post anyway.
- Yahoo Life
Suzanne Somers revealed the key to aging happily on her new Yahoo Life series "Unapologetically Suzanne."
Iran on Sunday issued a formal denial that it was behind the major Thursday night drone attack on the Mercer Street oil tanker off Oman
Anyone who’s despondent over the way it can sometimes feel like we’re all stuck these days in a coronavirus time loop — reliving the same insanity about masks and vaccines over and over again — allow us to remind you of one perfectly acceptable means of sanity preservation. There’s always the siren song of a … The post Everyone’s talking about this suspenseful Netflix drama that just rocketed to #1 appeared first on BGR.
- NBC Sports Boston
Ben Simmons reportedly is available on the trade market, but the Sixers' asking price for the 25-year-old guard is incredibly high.
- Business Insider
The Army rejected the M50 Ontos outright, but the Marines embraced it, putting it on the front lines of the Vietnam War's heaviest fighting.
Only four states have been affected.
- Women's Health
Hello Pilates booty.