By Lawrence Hurley WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday modestly cut back on software patents by ruling that simply implementing an abstract idea using a computer does not make an invention eligible to be patented. On a 9-0 vote, the court ruled for CLS Bank International, which challenged patents held by Australia-based Alice Corporation Pty Ltd for a computer system that facilitates financial transactions. The court added some clarity to a confused area of the law concerning when software can be patented but did not provide a definitive test on when software can be patented as some had hoped. The ruling left open questions about under what circumstances the use of a computer adds enough to the idea to make it patent eligible. At a minimum, the ruling is likely to help tech companies fend off lawsuits filed by "patent trolls," defined as companies that hold patents only for the purpose of suing firms seeking to develop new products. "It's going to clear away a lot of illegitimate claims pretty quickly," said Andrew Pincus, a lawyer with the Mayer Brown law firm who filed a brief on behalf of a technology trade group. The ruling in some ways mirrors a 2010 case, Bilski v. Kappos, in which the court was expected to offer guidance on business method patents but eventually issued a relatively narrow 9-0 decision. In Thursday's majority opinion, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that the outcome was determined by two of the court's recent patent rulings. "We hold that the claims at issue are drawn to the abstract idea of intermediated settlement and that merely requiring generic computer implementation fails to transform that abstract idea into a patent-eligible invention," Thomas wrote. The legal question boiled down to how innovative an invention should be to receive legal protection. The U.S. Patent Act states that anyone who "invents or discovers a new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter," or an improvement of an existing one, can get a patent. An invention related to an abstract idea can be patented, but it must include a way of applying the idea. Google Inc , Dell Inc , Verizon Communications Inc, and Microsoft Corp were among the companies that filed legal papers weighing in on the issue. Companies differ over what kind of eligibility threshold they would prefer. Those that often get sued for patent infringement, such as Google, favor a tighter definition. Those that want to protect their own patents, such as IBM Corp, would prefer that most software be patent eligible. In May 2013, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit ruled for CLS but the judges were split 5-5 on which legal test to adopt. The case is Alice Corp v. CLS Bank, U.S. Supreme Court, No.13-298 (Reporting by Lawrence Hurley; Editing by Howard Goller and Grant McCool)
Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting
- USA TODAY Sports
Dak Prescott should be ashamed of himself – and not because of squandering the final seconds off the clock in Cowboys' wild-card playoff loss.
- Steelers Wire
Ben Roethlisberger and Patrick Mahomes are planning a jersey swap.
- Yahoo Life
The supermodel, who turns 68 on Feb. 2, appears to be vacationing in the Caribbean.
- The Hill
Conservative pundit Ann Coulter is predicting the end of Donald Trump's hegemony in the GOP, saying the former president "is done.""Trump is done," Coulter, a onetime Trump booster turned critic, wrote in an email to The New York Times. "You guys should stop obsessing over him."Coulter's comments came in an article published in the Times on Sunday about the mounting tensions between Trump and Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) amid speculation of a...
- The Daily Beast
ROBYN BECK/AFP via Getty ImagesThere was a time when Donald Trump made news with his rallies—when he said things that utterly shocked us. Who could forget the firestorm he started, for example, when he went after Colin Kaepernick and other NFL players who knelt during the national anthem in 2017, or earlier that year when he called Barack Obama “the founder of ISIS”?Trump’s performance in Arizona on Saturday night—his first rally in months and his much-hyped chance to respond to the one-year ann
- USA TODAY
Am I wrong for not letting my sister-in-law, 26, and her four kids (ages 1 to 8) stay at my house for a few days? I need advice on my family drama.
- Good Housekeeping
Frances Berwick of NBCUniversal Television gave an update for fans about the 22nd season of 'The Voice' on NBC, and viewers aren't going to be happy about it.
- Patriots Wire
Bill Belichick had a very simple reasoning for the Patriots' embarrassing playoff loss to the Bills.
Jordan Cashmyer, a woman who was featured on MTV’s “16 and Pregnant” in 2014, died in Maryland on Sunday. She was 26 years old. News of Cashmyer’s death was shared by her stepmother, Jessica Cashmyer, through a post written on the Facebook account of the Dennis M. Cashmyer Jr., her husband and Jordan’s father. A […]
- ProFootball Talk on NBC Sports
Sunday’s game between the Eagles and the Buccaneers included a moment during which Tampa Bay coach Bruce Arians went after defensive back Andrew Adams, physically. It came after a muffed punt by Philadelphia receiver Jalen Reagor. Arians, in order to keep Adams from drawing a flag for pulling an opponent off the pile, slapped Adams [more]
- NBC Sports BayArea
Not many people are happier than Stephen A. Smith to see the Cowboys lose Sunday.
- Washington Football Wire
Ryan Fitzpatrick was in attendance for the Bills' blowout wild-card win over the Patriots Saturday — as a shirtless fan.
- NBC Sports
Coco Gauff and Sofia Kenin, the two highest-ranked Americans, were the two women's seeds eliminated on the opening day of the Australian Open.
The couple first got engaged in August 2019 and now share 1½-year-old son River
- Business Insider
The world's 10 richest men have made so much money during the pandemic that a one-time 99% tax on their gains could pay for all COVID-19 vaccine production and more: Oxfam
Oxfam calculated that the wealth of the world's 10 richest men grew by $15,000 a second — $1.3 billion a day — from March 2020 to November 2021.
I can't imagine surviving winter without this hack.View Entire Post ›
Trump claims he couldn't have lost the 2020 presidential election because his Arizona rally boasted thousands of attendees and had 'cars that stretch out for 25 miles'
"There's nobody that can see the end of this crowd," Donald Trump told supporters at a Saturday rally. "That's not somebody that lost an election."
- Atlanta Black Star
Savannah James has broken the internet with several beautiful looks in the last few months and now she’s serving up another grown and sexy vibe […]
- The Daily Advertiser
Here's how 5-star QB Arch Manning fits in with these five potential college suitors.
- NBC Sports BayArea
Kyle Shanahan explains the fourth-down gaffe that could have cost the 49ers the game.