US election 2020: Do postal ballots lead to voting fraud?

Reality Check team - BBC News
·4 min read
An elderly woman in a protective hood prepared to post her ballot in a mail box
An elderly woman in a protective hood prepared to post her ballot in a mail box

President Trump has criticised the expansion of postal voting in the presidential election, claiming it leads to widespread fraud - but what evidence is there?

The US is in uncharted territory during the coronavirus pandemic with a record number of Americans having voted by post.

"Mail-in ballots are very dangerous - there's tremendous fraud involved.", Source: Donald Trump, Source description: US President, Image:
"Mail-in ballots are very dangerous - there's tremendous fraud involved.", Source: Donald Trump, Source description: US President, Image:

Election authorities and the postal service have been put under immense strain processing the millions of extra ballots.

This has led to claims the system is unsafe and susceptible to manipulation.

Problems at previous elections?

Numerous national and state-level studies have shown that although there have been isolated cases, electoral fraud is very rare.

There have been a few, well-publicised cases, such as in the 2018 North Carolina primary, which was re-run after a consultant for the Republican candidate tampered with voting papers.

But the rate of voting fraud overall in the US is less than 0.0009%, according to a 2017 study by the Brennan Center for Justice.

And Federal Election Commission head Ellen Weintraub has said: "There's simply no basis for the conspiracy theory that voting by mail causes fraud."

Trump addresses press
Trump addresses press

Let's look at some specific examples where fraud has been claimed this year.

Virginia

Speaking at a rally in mid-October, Donald Trump said: "In Virginia, 500,000 applications were made that were false."

And these applications, to apply for an absentee ballot form, were sent out with the wrong return address.

But the electoral authorities in Virginia say there was no fraudulent intent and the mistake has been corrected.

The Virginia Center for Voter Information (CVI) said: "We worked for weeks to make sure that no Virginia voter was inconvenienced as a result of our printing error."

Man in a black face mask returns his mail-in ballot
Man in a black face mask returns his mail-in ballot

Ohio

President Trump tweeted: "In Ohio, 50,000 ballots were wrong, fraudulent - 50,000."

About 50,000 voters did receive the wrong ballot in the post, in Franklin County, Ohio, in early October.

But there is no evidence this was done fraudulently.

And the local elections board said everyone affected was sent the correct voter slip, with safeguards in place to ensure no-one voted twice.

The board said the ballot error had been a "serious mistake".

But in response to the president's tweet, it added: "Our board is bipartisan and our elections are fair - and every vote will be counted."

  • In New York, nearly 100,000 ballots were resent to voters after some names and addresses were printed incorrectly.

  • In Michigan about 400 postal ballots listed the wrong running mate for President Trump - the Libertarian Party's Jeremy Cohen instead of Mike Pence. President Trump claimed in September this had been deliberate. But the Michigan secretary of state said it had been an error and "impacted voters immediately received an accurate ballot and guidance to ensure their vote counts".

  • In Wisconsin, mail that included some absentee ballots was found in a ditch near the town of Greenville. How this happened remains unclear, despite investigation. The White House alleged fraud.

  • In Pennsylvania, nine discarded military ballots were discovered. Seven of them, according to the US Department for Justice, "were cast for presidential candidate Donald Trump".

  • In New Jersey, a mail carrier was charged after dumping hundreds of items of post in a dumpster, including almost 100 election ballots. Once found, the mail was sent on to its intended recipients.

But these were all isolated incidents.

And there remains overwhelming evidence that voting by post is safe and secure.

There are provisions in place to prevent people from impersonating voters or stealing ballots - such as authorities checking that ballots have come from voters' registered address and requiring signatures on envelopes.

These safeguards are being applied to all postal votes.

How is the postal system coping?

A record number of people have voted by post this time round, with more than 65 million sent in, according to one compilation of data from different states.

Mail in ballots waiting to be processed in USPS trays
Mail in ballots waiting to be processed in USPS trays

In August, the head of the US Postal Service, Louis DeJoy, told lawmakers that the service was "fully capable and committed" to handling postal votes.

He said he would postpone a proposed restructuring of the postal system after controversy arose over whether his changes could delay the delivery of mail during the election.

Banner
Banner
Reality Check branding
Reality Check branding

Read more from Reality Check

Send us your questions

Follow us on Twitter