I used extreme couponing tips for my holiday shopping. It was time-consuming, but it changed the way I shop online.

I used extreme couponing tips for my holiday shopping. It was time-consuming, but it changed the way I shop online.
  • Shows like "Extreme Couponing" exposed viewers to a lifestyle dedicated to getting the best deal.

  • As Black Friday becomes bigger, people have become experts at using coupons.

  • I used a few tips and tricks from couponing experts to get my holiday shopping out of the way.

  • This article is part of "Better Holidays," a series highlighting different ways to make holiday celebrations easier and memorable.

With Black Friday approaching, I wanted to get some of my holiday shopping out of the way as early as possible.

I consider myself to be moderately good at getting deals. I use Honey, a browser extension that automatically applies discount codes at checkout so you know you're getting the best price. I've been known to price check at big-box stores like Target. And I have two store credit cards that rack up points.

But extreme couponing is a whole different beast. As seen on shows like TLC's "Extreme Couponing," which aired for two years, it involves planning, research, and lots of time spent comparing prices.

I knew if I wanted to try it, I'd need to reach out to some experts to get the best deals. Here's how it went.

I got advice from two experts: Clay Cary, the lead analyst at CouponFollow, and Oleg Segal, the CEO of DealA.

With AFP Story by Fabienne Faur: Lifestyle-US-economy-consumer Coupons from the advertising section of the Sunday newspaper September 13, 2011 in Washington, DC. The humble coupon -- which is the past gave consumers a few cents off soap or cereal -- has mushroomed into a lifestyle for millions of Americans with its own television programs, websites and trading platforms.
Clipping coupons is just the start.KAREN BLEIER/Getty Images

CouponFollow and DealA are websites that compile coupons from across the internet for different brands, stores, and manufacturers.

Cary pointed me to another community where I could get more tips: Reddit.

r couponing reddit
The homepage for r/Couponing.Reddit

"These communities often share exclusive, location-specific deals, flash sale notifications, or even methods to combine promotions in ways not explicitly advertised," Cary told Insider, regarding internet spaces like Reddit, Facebook, and TikTok.

I found that Reddit was the easiest to use, specifically, r/Couponing. I was able to find apps, browser extensions, and more from my time on this Reddit board.

Through Reddit, I was pointed to two cash-back apps: Shopmium and Ibotta. I chose to use Ibotta.

ibotta
The homepage of Ibotta.Ibotta

Cash-back apps are exactly what they sound like: apps that, when you upload your receipt or use the app or website to shop online, you get cash back, as long as you make an account.

These apps also tend to recommend buying gift cards and then using them to buy things for a cheaper price, a common shopping hack.

However, Ibotta requires using a debit card to purchase gift cards, and I never use my debit card to online shop in case it gets hacked — I learned that one the hard way.

Apps like Ibotta, Honey, and Shopmium all have various offers linked to retailers around the country.

I chose to use Ibotta because it seemed to have more brands that I'd be using for holiday shopping than Shopmium, which might be more ideal for grocery shopping.

When using Ibotta, you must make sure that your purchases are eligible.

walmart codes
What works at Walmart.Ibotta

There were many categories that were eligible for this 10% cash back offer at Walmart, for example.

But what wasn't eligible? Groceries and food, tires, video game hardware, any Apple products, and gift cards.

It's an extra step to double-check your purchases are covered, but it's worth it to make sure you're getting the best deal.

I tried Sephora first, since I have a Sephora credit card and therefore already get discounts.

A Sephora storefront with people walking along a sidewalk
A Sephora store.Mary Altaffer/AP Photo

Using Ibotta is simple. First, I searched Sephora on the website, clicked the Shop button, and was automatically able to get 2% cash back on my purchase.

Something I didn't count on, though, was not being able to use Honey, the browser extension that compiles coupons, in conjunction with Ibotta.

honey error message
The Honey error message.Sephora; Honey

Instead, I had to open a new tab, go to my Sephora cart again, and then copy and paste the coupon code I wanted to use in the original Ibotta affiliate tab.

This wasn't difficult, but just an extra step — something I discovered is commonplace in the couponing community. It's not hard, just a little time-consuming.

In addition to the 2% cash-back, I was able to use a code to get a free lip gloss. I also had $15 worth of rewards between Sephora VIB points and my store card.

laneige gift set
A Laneige gift set I purchased.Sephora

Overall, my purchase of two gift sets and a face mask for $49 actually turned into the gift sets, the face mask, a lip-gloss sample, and two customary free Sephora samples for $34 (before tax) — plus the cash back from Ibotta.

I thought it was a good first attempt.

My mom has mentioned to me in passing that she's sick of her Keurig and wants to go back to a classic coffee maker. Like any good gift-giver, I added this to a note in my phone.

Keurig on display at Southern Kitchen Brunch hosted by Trisha Yearwood, part of The New York Times series during the 2015 Food Network & Cooking Channel South Beach Wine & Food Festival presented by FOOD & WINE at Loews Miami Beach Hotel on February 22, 2015
A Keurig.Sergi Alexander/Getty Images

Since there's no time like the present (no pun intended), a coffee maker was my next attempted coupon purchase.

My mom already enjoys Ninja products, and Ninja was one of the brands that gets cash back on Ibotta, so I decided to try my luck and see if I could find any good deals.

I decided on the Ninja 12-cup Programmable Coffee Maker, which Wirecutter called the best "cheap" coffee maker, even though it can cost between $70 to $96 online.

ninja coffee maker
The Ninja Coffee Maker I purchased.Home Depot

Ibotta and Honey both recommended purchasing the coffee-maker from Home Depot, but I'm still not sure that the $69.99 sale price is the best price I'm going to get — however, Home Depot guarantees price-matching within 30 days of purchase.

So, if I find a better deal within a month of this purchase, Home Depot will match the price.

I decided to take the plunge and buy it (and get 4% cash back on Ibotta), but I added the product to a watchlist on the Ibotta app; I'll be able to see if it drops in price anywhere across the internet.

I also signed up for email blasts from Home Depot, which gave me an additional $5 off.

The coffee maker itself was on sale for 13% off — normally it's $79.99. So, with the $10 off, plus the $5 sign-up code, the coffee maker was brought down to $64.99, around 19% off total.

The last thing I attempted to get a deal on are the platform Uggs that everyone's obsessed with these days.

platform uggs
Platform Uggs.Jeremy Moeller/Getty Images

I heard the recommendation from Segal, "Remember, a deal is only a deal if you need the item in the first place," ringing in my ears as I embarked on the journey to find the best deal for these.

Are these totally necessary for my day-to-day life? No, but my millennial nostalgia kicked into overdrive when I discovered that Uggs are "cool again," and I want to relive my glory days.

This time, I used CouponFollow, the site that Cary is an analyst for. I saw multiple coupons, but unfortunately, Ugg doesn't allow coupon stacking.

Jennifer Gammell sorts coupons for Black Friday in Torrance, Calif., Nov. 23, 2017. Many so-called Black Friday bargains are undesirable products that have been marked down to help stores clear out inventory, but some categories -- game consoles, televisions and smart home gadgets among them -- are worth close attention.
Coupon stacking in action.San Francisco Chronicle/Hearst Newspapers/Getty Images

Both Cary and Segal recommended finding retailers that allow "coupon stacking," or the practice of using multiple coupons on the same order.

According to couponing blog The Krazy Coupon Lady, stores like Kohl's, Old Navy, Amazon, Target, and Michael's all allow coupon stacking, with some stores allowing for unlimited coupons on a single order.

This wasn't totally helpful for my holiday shopping spree, but I could see how coupon stacking would be an absolute game-changer when grocery shopping. I'll be trying it the next time I go.

Ibotta provides .5% cash back at Ugg, which is pretty minuscule, but better than nothing.

uggs
Another pair of Ugg boots.Ralf Geithe/Getty Images

After trying many different expired coupon codes, I eventually found one that got me free expedited shipping.

I also used AfterPay, which allows you to break purchases up into smaller bi-weekly payments. These will be fully paid off at some point in December.

They were $160 before tax, so my installments will be something like $45 every two weeks.

But we'll see if I make the ultimate couponing move: returning them if I spy a better deal on Cyber Monday.

Segal and Cary gave me other tips that weren't applicable to these purchases, but I'll keep them in mind for Black Friday and other shopping trips.

black friday
A store on Black Friday.Stephen Chernin/Getty Images

Cary recommended an app called ScanLife, which allows you to scan items in-store in order to ensure you're getting the best deal. In places that price match, like Target, this could be the ticket to saving you a good amount of cash.

He also told me that some stores have specific promotion days, when the brand magnifies values of coupons and codes. Searching social media (like Reddit and TikTok) is the best way to find out those days.

Cary also told me that engaging with brands on social media, participating in polls and surveys, and using promotional hashtags are all solid ways to get discounts.

Segal recommended all of those things, and reiterated that I should be starting early. Stores like Walmart are already advertising Black Friday deals.

He also told me that remaining organized is key. You don't want to be fumbling with various clippings at the register, holding up an antsy line.

I might not spend the same amount of time and energy researching deals for every purchase, but Ibotta and Honey are now both part of my shopping routine.

sephora deals
Honey activating Sephora deals.Sephora; Honey

According to Ibotta, it takes seven days for your rewards to come in, so I'm excited to see how much money I've accumulated so far.

I'm already looking forward to Black Friday and Cyber Monday, armed with my new couponing knowledge.

Read the original article on Insider