West Virginia state police superintendent resigns amid probe

CHARLESTON, W.Va. (AP) — West Virginia Gov. Jim Justice on Monday ordered a sweeping investigation of the State Police after he accepted the resignation of the agency's superintendent and revealed allegations of wrongdoing, including that a video camera was placed inside a women's locker room.

The governor also said the investigation will look into an unspecified "loss of life" on Interstate 81 in the Eastern Panhandle. Based on media reports, the incident appears to be one from February in which a Hagerstown man died after a confrontation with a trooper.

Justice said he has appointed Jack Chambers, the deputy director of the Capitol police, as interim superintendent to replace Superintendent Jan Cahill, who had served under Justice since the governor took office in 2017. Justice said Chambers will conduct "an all-out investigation" to replace one that started last month under Cahill and was nearing its completion.

I-81 incident involved Hagerstown man

Justice did not provide details of the I-81 incident, including when it occurred. The governor said he has seen video of what happened and it is "very, very concerning." An investigation is ongoing, "and Jack Chambers has to get into this as well," Justice said.

The incident appears to be one The Herald-Mail reported previously where state police said a trooper responded to I-81 about 2 1/2 miles north of the North Queen Street exit near Martinsburg around 9:15 p.m. Feb. 12 for a person walking south on the highway.

Related:West Virginia authorities investigating death of male after officer struggle

The trooper found Edmond Exline, 44, of Virginia Avenue in Hagerstown, and a brief struggle occurred. Exline became unresponsive and troopers were unsuccessful in reviving him at the scene, police said.

Exline later died at Berkeley Medical Center and an investigation is underway, state police said.

The Herald-Mail filed a Freedom of Information Act request with state police asking for any dash camera or body camera footage of the incident shortly after the incident. State police denied the request.

Related:WV State Police cite legal exemptions to deny records involving Hagerstown man's death

Three troopers were placed on paid administrative leave pending the investigation's completion, according to the Associated Press.

State police initially said they responded to I-81 for an intoxicated male walking on the interstate. But Exline's sister-in-law, Sarah Exline of Hagerstown, said in a phone interview previously that she finds it hard to believe her brother-in-law had been drinking.

Related:Family says man who died after police struggle on I-81 had mental illness

She said Edmond suffered from mental health issues and he was afraid of consuming anything like alcohol for fear that it would complicate his condition.

Discovery of video camera occurred before Cahill placed in charge

One focus of the investigation will be an allegation that a State Police employee hid a video camera in the women's locker room at a State Police facility in Kanawha County.

"To me, it is absolutely not to be tolerated in any way," Justice said.

Justice did not specify when it occurred but indicated it was several years ago, perhaps before Cahill took over, and that the employee involved later died of an apparent heart attack while jogging.

Justice said three troopers eventually found a thumb drive "and from that they found the video." At least one of the troopers "jerked the thumb drive out, threw it to the floor and started stomping on it. You can't make this stuff up, can you? Now we've got law enforcement officers destroying evidence."

Justice acknowledged that "maybe we won't be able to recover much information. Maybe many troopers are long gone. Maybe there's no way to recover evidence. But we ought to try, because we're better than this."

Investigation into allegedly stolen cash at casino didn't start immediately

A separate incident that will be investigated involved money allegedly stolen by a trooper from a man at a casino in the Charleston suburb of Nitro.

A man was playing a video machine with a trooper close by, Justice said. As the man got up to go to the restroom, an envelope with him fell out of his seat. The trooper picked up the envelope and kept the money inside.

"Basically any way you cut it, that money was stolen," Justice said.

The governor said State Police should have immediately begun an investigation, but "we didn't do that." The governor did not specify whether the trooper was disciplined.

Another incident in Eastern Panhandle 'cast a dark shadow'

In a November 2018 incident that Justice said "cast a dark shadow" on law enforcement, a police dashcam video showed an officer kicking and punching a handcuffed teenage boy on the ground and kneeling on his shoulder during a traffic stop in the Eastern Panhandle.

Related:West Virginia State Police superintendent says in-car camera captures teen being thrown

State Police said the teen was involved in a crash with a sheriff's cruiser before a pursuit ensued, his vehicle crashing again before he was apprehended.

Related:Berkeley County Sheriff's deputy to return to duty after hearing board overrules sheriff

Two troopers were fired before one of them won his job back. Two sheriff's deputies also were fired and later reinstated.

Justice met with Cahill at superintendent's request

Chambers served a combined 26 years with the Capitol police and State Police. The Capitol police, also known as the Division of Protective Services, was established in 1999 to provide security at the state Capitol Complex in Charleston and other state facilities.

Justice said he met with Cahill at the superintendent's request Monday morning at the governor's residence, when Cahill submitted his resignation.

"I stand with and behind our police on every issue up to the point in time when it goes beyond what is right," Justice said.

Before becoming superintendent, Cahill served as the sheriff in Greenbrier County, where the governor has a home and owns the posh Greenbrier resort. Before that, Cahill spent 23 years with the State Police in a variety of roles. He started as a field trooper in 1989 and retired as troop commander captain in Beckley in 2012, the year he was elected to the first of two terms as sheriff.

Associated Press writer John Raby contributed to this story.

This article originally appeared on The Herald-Mail: WV state police leader resigns; death of man on I-81 part of probe