Chilling details emerge in court of 'execution style' slaying at Brockton sushi restaurant

BROCKTON — A judge ordered two men held without bail Tuesday in what District Attorney Tim Cruz called an "execution-style" shooting in a crowded buffet restaurant.

Jamal Augereau Bazile, 18, and Nathan Veiga, 22, pleaded not guilty to murdering Joe Araujo, 22, of Brockton. Prosecutors claim Veiga scouted the Hibachi Sushi Supreme on Crescent Street for Bazile on Friday evening, confirming that the victim was there with his girlfriend.

Then Bazile walked into the restaurant at 7:24 p.m, picked up a "to-go" container and went to where the victim and girlfriend were sitting. Prosecutors say Bazile dropped the container, pulled out a gun and fired three shots.

"He conducted a brazen indoor execution in front of small children," Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague said during a Tuesday arraignment at Brockton District Court.

The arrest Pair arrested in connection with deadly shooting at Brockton's Hibachi Sushi Supreme

From left, Attorney Eduardo Masferrer, his client Nathan Veiga, defendant Jamal Augereau Bazile and his attorney Louis Badwey are in Brockton District Court on Tuesday, Jan. 16, 2024, for Veiga and Bazile's arraignments in connection with a fatal shooting at a city sushi restaurant on Friday evening, Jan. 12, 2024.
From left, Attorney Eduardo Masferrer, his client Nathan Veiga, defendant Jamal Augereau Bazile and his attorney Louis Badwey are in Brockton District Court on Tuesday, Jan. 16, 2024, for Veiga and Bazile's arraignments in connection with a fatal shooting at a city sushi restaurant on Friday evening, Jan. 12, 2024.

What the prosecution said in court

Two bullets struck Araujo, hitting him in the abdomen and leg. He was pronounced dead later at Good Samaritan Medical Center.

Sprague said the girlfriend, whom she did not name in court, said Araujo called Veiga "ops" — slang for an opposing faction.

Sprague said the shooting was "payback" for a February 2022 murder. The Enterprise has asked the Plymouth County District Attorney's Office to confirm which murder that was. The veteran prosecutor said Bazile and Veiga belong to the "East Side Boys" and that Araujo was in an opposing group.

Sprague told the court that investigators searched Veiga's bedroom and found a distinctive Nike jacket like the one worn by the shooter in surveillance video. Sprague said that search also uncovered crack cocaine. The assistant district attorney also said investigators fingerprints found on the dropped to-go container matched those of Bazile's middle fingers.

Bazile acted with "complete disregard to the physical, mental, emotional well being of everyone in that restaurant," Sprague said.

Graphic surveillance video released Video shows brazen fatal shooting inside Brockton sushi restaurant

Ana Inacio, the mother of the Joe Araujo, 22, who was shot to death on Friday evening, Jan. 12, 2024, at a sushi restaurant in Brockton, attends the arraignment for the two defendants in Brockton District Court on Tuesday, Jan. 16, 2024.
Ana Inacio, the mother of the Joe Araujo, 22, who was shot to death on Friday evening, Jan. 12, 2024, at a sushi restaurant in Brockton, attends the arraignment for the two defendants in Brockton District Court on Tuesday, Jan. 16, 2024.

What defense attorney said

Veiga's attorney, Eduardo A. Masferrer, said his client denies ever going into the restaurant, and that he didn't case the place for Bazile. Masferrer said Veiga has cooperated with law enforcement by going to Brockton Police on his own.

Investigators from Brockton Police and Massachusetts State Police worked the case over the weekend. They located Bazile at a home in Hyannis on Monday evening. Sprague said he struggled with officers before being taken into custody. She said police found a loaded gun in his sweatshirt pocket.

From left, Attorney Eduardo Masferrer, his client Nathan Veiga, defendant Jamal Augereau Bazile and his attorney Louis Badwey are in Brockton District Court on Tuesday, Jan. 16, 2024, for Veiga and Bazile's arraignments in connection with a fatal shooting at a city sushi restaurant on Friday evening, Jan. 12, 2024.
From left, Attorney Eduardo Masferrer, his client Nathan Veiga, defendant Jamal Augereau Bazile and his attorney Louis Badwey are in Brockton District Court on Tuesday, Jan. 16, 2024, for Veiga and Bazile's arraignments in connection with a fatal shooting at a city sushi restaurant on Friday evening, Jan. 12, 2024.

Bail denied

Judge Michael A. Vitali denied the defendants' bail on Tuesday. He's the same judge who on Dec. 4, 2023, set $5,000 cash bail for Bazile on charges of carrying a firearm without a license, Sprague said.

Ana Inacio the mother of the late Joe Araujo, 22, left, with her daughters during the murder trial for Nathan Veiga, and Jamal Augereau Bazile at Brockton District Court on Tuesday, Jan. 16, 2024.
Ana Inacio the mother of the late Joe Araujo, 22, left, with her daughters during the murder trial for Nathan Veiga, and Jamal Augereau Bazile at Brockton District Court on Tuesday, Jan. 16, 2024.

'Significant' event for Brockton

Cruz attended Tuesday's arraignment in person. Speaking to reporters after the court session, he called the killing a "brazen, premeditated act" and a "significant event" for the city of Brockton. Cruz declined to criticize Vitali's Dec. 4 bail ruling. Cruz said his office had sought bail of $10,000 and imposition of a GPS monitoring bracelet.

Araujo's sister and mother declined to comment.

Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz at a presser after the murder arraignments for Nathan Veiga, and Jamal Augereau at Brockton District Court on Tuesday, Jan. 16, 2024.
Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz at a presser after the murder arraignments for Nathan Veiga, and Jamal Augereau at Brockton District Court on Tuesday, Jan. 16, 2024.

What happens next?

Court officials set Feb. 13 as the next court date, which will be a probable cause hearing for Bazile and Veiga. Bazile is charged with murder, possession of a firearm, possession of ammunition and discharge of a firearm. Veiga is charged with murder and accessory to murder before the fact.

Send your news tips to reporter Chris Helms by email at CHelms@enterprisenews.com or connect on X at @HelmsNews.

This article originally appeared on The Enterprise: Brockton sushi restaurant murder suspects held without bail